Re:Why Do People Who Need Help from the Government Hate It S...
by bostik on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:37AM
(#12537585)
I recognise that excerpt. The Gods Themselves, by Asimov.
Of his works that I've read, "optimistic" is not the word I would associate with this particular book. It is cynical from the outset, with even the prologue making a point that scientific progress is mostly achieved out of spite.
As for the solution to the problem in the book ... IIRC it happens mostly by accident. The underlying tone in the story is that despite the importance of scientific advances, the driving force is always that of a personal vendetta. After all, in the story Lamont spends his career seeking revenge, trying to find a way to shoot the messenger of the uninformed and dangerous view.
Optimistic? I prefer jaded.
EDIT: originally I remembered it was a Heinlein book. Changed to Asimov.
Re:Why Do People Who Need Help from the Government Hate It S...
by snowwrestler on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:31AM
(#12537562)
For those not familiar with it, the above quote is from "The Gods Themselves" by Isaac Asimov--a very good science fiction novel.
‘Now then, young man, don’t ask me to stop the Pumping. The economy and comfort of the entire planet depend on it. Tell me, instead, how to keep the Pumping from exploding the Sun.’
Lamont said, ‘There is no way, Senator. We are dealing with something here that is so basic, we can’t play with it. We must stop it.’
‘Ah, and you suggest only that we go back to matters as they were before Pumping.’
‘We must.’
‘In that case, you will need hard and fast proof you are right.’
‘The best proof,’ Lamont said stiffly, ‘is to have the Sun explode.'”
There is always a tension between short term gains and long term planning. I think history, economics, psychology, behavioral economics all pretty much agree that most people are terrible at long term planning and they will consistently sacrifice long term gains for short term gains in exchange for a much worse future for all involved.
I'm not as optimistic as the author of that book. I don't think there is a way to crack this nut and get long term thinking to be the norm. When even people who have cancer because of the kind of environment they live in are voting to weaken the power of the EPA what hope is there?