News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vector is now called Riot by pomfpomfpomf3 on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:39PM (#12533162)
Vector (+Matrix) is kinda like self-hosted slack/discord with proper history sync across all your devices, file uploads, nice UI, etc.

It's really good. I recommended it to 7 people and every single one liked it, even got 5 of them to set up their own federated homeservers. We're thinking about moving a ~60-people skype group there as well.

Only issue I had is Synapse hogging the CPU and getting laggy with a large room (#matrix:matrix.org with its 4 thousand members). I'm using scaleway's 3 EUR/month Starter VC1S server for Synapse though. Hopefully it will get even better with time.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by amandine on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:57PM (#12533293)
Synapse 0.18.0 has just been released, might worth giving it a try as it improves things a bit.

Thanks for the support :)

Re:Vector is now called Riot by vertex-four on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:55PM (#12533285)
Synapse does calm down once it's sorted everything out, luckily.
Re:Vector is now called Riot by kuschku on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:07PM (#12533372)
Or you could just use IRC with quassel + quassel-webserver, and get basically all of the same, but with an actual open protocol. Which actually has support.
Re:Vector is now called Riot by mxuribe on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:13PM (#12533417)
Actually matrix - the protocol upon which vector and now riot depend - is an open protocol; reference here: http://matrix.org/docs/spec/

And then of course, there are the matrix bridges to IRC, etc. Admittedly although i have been using vector clients AND have installed my own personal synapse server, i have no experience using/supporting the various matrix bridges, so can't speak to their quality.

That being said, if you've ever been curious about re-doing some aspects of IRC for the better, you might want to take a look at matrix (the protocol), and suggest improvements; we all stand to benefit from your (and the community's) suggestions.

[dead]
Re:Vector is now called Riot by vertex-four on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:51PM (#12533749)
So who's working on federation and single identity across IRC networks? Who's working on a protocol which would let me ask other users for their chat logs from before I joined a channel? Who's working on WebRTC signalling over IRC? When will bouncers be built into IRC servers so I don't have to run my own? When will IRC have a standardised HTTP protocol by which I can run whatever webclient, mobile client, or otherwise that I want? When will it support proprietary push services to keep mobile battery life up?

IRC has had 28 years to do any one of these things.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by reitanqild on Monday September 19, 2016 @03:32PM (#12534042)
> My suggestion: stop the project, burn the code.

> Seriously, by splitting up the dev effort between yet one more project, the open source community ends up with even more competing standards.

Oh come on: there is no lack of developer time, so many developers are rotting away in front of TVs.

There is however a lack of developer motivation to do open source projects.

If anyone wants to work on this instead of wasting their life in front of the tv, thumbs up from me.

+ as already has been pointed out, matrix seems to go way way beyond irc.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by kuschku on Monday September 19, 2016 @05:46PM (#12535030)
It’s not just about developer time, it’s also about the users.

The amount of users willing to use an open source chat system is limited.

If we want to profit from the same network effects that proprietary chat systems profit from, we need to get everyone into one system, which also scales to extreme scales, and, yes, allows content censoring on some level – but also allows anyone to open their own federated server with different censoring policies.

Adding more standards doesn’t help, unless they federate both ways.

(Although Matrix is the least problematic example there, Signal is far worse in those regards)

Re:Vector is now called Riot by reitanqild on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:45AM (#12538043)
> Adding more standards doesn’t help, unless they federate both ways.

> (Although Matrix is the least problematic example there, Signal is far worse in those regards)

Not everyone in open source is out here to dethrone proprietary systems (although many of us have "enemies", my personal one ATM is Oracle, although with a smile, -I wouldn't sabotage them even if I could get away with it but I love to tell people about alternatives)

Some are just experimenting, some are building reputation, some are just out here to make the world a better place for everyone etc.

Telling people who produce nice useful stuff to "stop the project, burn the code" is, IMO, rude and harmful.

Edit: Let me add, - thanks a whole lot for working on opensource and on irc specifically. Many of us here love IRC and the reason why I downvoted one of your earlier comments is because we don't think anyone should be allowed to tell people what open source projects they should or should not start or contribute to.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by kuschku on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @06:21AM (#12538360)
The user I replied to asked me what I’d suggest to fix with Matrix, or change with it.

So I replied honestly.

I knew most wouldn’t like the answer, but it’s still what I’d do.

I also didn’t suggest to actually do it – just that that would be what I’d do, if it was my responsibility.

> some are just out here to make the world a better place for everyone etc.

and

> Not everyone in open source is out here to dethrone proprietary systems

Are the same, though.

It’s just that if we want to compete with products that have multiple-billion-dollar marketing budgets, have thousands of paid engineers working on perfectly planned timelines, etc, we really need to coordinate.

The "let’s go and everyone build their own" is good for hobby projects, but as soon as it comes to building something for users to actually use, you need quality control, coordinated branding and marketing, you need focus of development, you need people doing QA and support.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by reitanqild on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @07:58AM (#12538804)
> The user I replied to asked me what I’d suggest to fix with Matrix, or change with it.

> So I replied honestly.

OK, I see I misunderstood your intentions.

I won't take all the blame for the misunderstanding though.

That said you managed to get me interested so if you don't mind:

Where should I start reading to read up on modern IRC?

And again: thanks a bunch for helping in maintaining an open-source project! Very much appreciated!

Re:Vector is now called Riot by kuschku on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @01:58PM (#12541646)
Regarding modern IRC, there’s http://ircv3.net/, the corresponding repo of specifications, https://github.com/ircv3/, and the IRC channel #ircv3 on freenode.

Also take a look at IRCCloud or Quassel or Weechat+GlowingBear to see what can be possible with IRC already today, if you use a modern bouncer. (Part of the work of IRCv3 is integrating that functionality again).

Re:Vector is now called Riot by Arathorn on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:44PM (#12533690)
Occasionally you need to re-baseline or you risk getting mired fighting backwards compatibility and the limitations of the original design. Just like Git "rewrote" Subversion. Or clang "rewrote" gcc. Or PNG "rewrote" GIF.

It's incredibly shortsighted to assume that attempts to create new projects that overlap with old ones are are splitting dev effort and harm overall progress.

Re:Vector is now called Riot by vertex-four on Monday September 19, 2016 @03:09PM (#12533888)
Matrix is not trying to split any community. If it were, it wouldn't have bridges to IRC, Slack, or any other chat system.

I'd like to see Freenode integrate a seamless bouncer. I suspect I won't in the next few years. Right now, Matrix provides one. Fancy that. (Also, I'm chatting across four different Matrix servers, with people in those rooms from many more, and have only ever had to manually connect to one server (my own) and have only had to create one account. IRC isn't working on fixing that.)