News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by lintiness on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:56AM (#12532387)
you don't think "political instability and so on" are related to chasing charity?
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by M_Grey on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:04PM (#12532432)
If you can find the link between the two in that article, please show me.
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by ctdonath on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:01PM (#12533326)
A large chunk of the article (middle of second page) covers this.

The problem is that political instability makes it very hard for long-term planning & efforts. If you're unsure what the political winds will bring next year, or who might be in power and how it will affect you, why would you invest in a long-term cash crop that takes years to pay off? To make sure you can provide for your family, you'd be wiser to focus on the food-crop harvest that's just a few months away, which is exactly what Haitian farmers do.

That makes "chasing charity" desirable: if you can't risk personal effort & cost for long term goals (see above), then by all means leverage what you can out of short-term donations. Practically all the infrastructure and equipment used by farmer cooperatives and associations were plopped down by an aid agency or nongovernmental organization. ... in turn, there are few incentives to make repairs when equipment fails, or to want to achieve long-term success generally. ...the [donated] gear is much too large for the low coffee yields and production levels in the country, and built in a style more suited for Central America. These aid-built facilities wind up operating at extremely low capacities and consequently with high labor, fuel, and water requirements. Most of them are so inefficient that they can't even break even—or at least they wouldn't be able to without support from outside aid groups.

There's a great deal more explaining this. RT*A.

Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by Symmetry on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:39PM (#12532709)
Yeah, there isn't really one in Haiti or necessarily one in general. But strongmen charging aid agencies for access to refugees has contributed to instability in some cases such as the Great Lakes refugee criss[1] which touched off the Congolese Civil War, one of the 20 deadliest human conflicts in history. If aid agencies are willing to walk away that isn't a problem, but not all of them are.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes_refugee_crisis

Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by M_Grey on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:16PM (#12532986)
To be honest, that seems to have been the product of a genocide which we did very little to prevent or palliate, far more than any actions by aid organizations. Quite a bit after the initial humanitarian crisis had eased, you did see the military takeover and there's little doubt that aid became problematic at that point.

The primary lesson though is that aid organizations can't handle a military without another military backing them. The UN couldn't make that happen, so the result was to promote conflict in the end.

Truly, that isn't even remotely analogues to the situation in Haiti.

Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by lintiness on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:04PM (#12532443)
maybe it was so obvious it didn't need linking.
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by M_Grey on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:08PM (#12532475)
Then you should have no problem showing me that link, obvious as you claim it to be.
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by ars on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:39PM (#12533642)
Political instability encourages short term thinking/planning, since long term is too risky.

The fastest way to make money from coffee is aid agencies.

If there was more long term thinking then the actual coffee would be a better way to make money. If there was no aid then ??? I'm not sure - either they would abandon coffee entirely, or they would be forced to actually try to grow coffee.

Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by M_Grey on Monday September 19, 2016 @03:35PM (#12534062)
If your long term thinking indicates that you need to grow the food you need to eat, that year, then how does coffee or aid enter the equation at all?
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by ars on Monday September 19, 2016 @03:42PM (#12534120)
Most food is grown on a single year basis - grow that year, eat that year.

Coffee is a tree it takes many many years to grow and develop. It's quicker to "harvest" money from aid agencies.

PS. Your reply is very strange, since the answer to your question is quite obvious. Are you actually trying to get info, or are you trying to push the message you desire via questions?

Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by M_Grey on Monday September 19, 2016 @04:26PM (#12534408)
I'm just hung up on the fairly large, and unsupported claim, "The fastest way to make money from coffee is aid agencies." Beyond that, to be blunt, I'm just not buying the fairly clumsy and shoehorned ideological narrative presented in the piece, especially when it explains the issues raised without actually needing to explain it in terms of abusing charity.
Re:Why Are Haiti's Coffee Trees So Tall? by MisterBastahrd on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:15PM (#12532527)
If you can find any links that make sense in that article, then you are probably a master detective who dresses up like a bat to put fear into the hearts of criminals. It's just a bunch of rambling nonsense gathered from National Geographic and Wikipedia with a nice clickbait title. I have to wonder if the writers at reason.com are being paid by word count given how vapid most of their articles are.