Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of...
by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:21PM
(#12527042)
I don't know about criminal punishment. It's a complicated issue. It is extremely problematic that journalists can play an active role in disseminating state secrets and absolve themselves of responsibility. Also: the Washington Post clearly crossed the line from advocate for the US public interest to... something else... in their choices of what to public from the Snowden cache.
I'm not here to argue that the Post wasn't hypocritical. They clearly were.
I'm just saying:
* Hypocrisy doesn't invalidate the Post's argument. We can despise the Post's Editorial Page editors as much as Greenwald wants us to and still reach the conclusion that the editorial is valid (though incomplete).
* Greenwald is so eager to cast aspersions at journalists who disagree with him that he roped Fred Kaplan into his piece, despite his having nothing (that I know of) to do with the Post's handling of Snowden. Simply because Kaplan is also a journalist, Greenwald believes he's not entitled to correct the record on Oliver Stone's terribly flawed movie.
I'm not here to argue that the Post wasn't hypocritical. They clearly were.
I'm just saying:
* Hypocrisy doesn't invalidate the Post's argument. We can despise the Post's Editorial Page editors as much as Greenwald wants us to and still reach the conclusion that the editorial is valid (though incomplete).
* Greenwald is so eager to cast aspersions at journalists who disagree with him that he roped Fred Kaplan into his piece, despite his having nothing (that I know of) to do with the Post's handling of Snowden. Simply because Kaplan is also a journalist, Greenwald believes he's not entitled to correct the record on Oliver Stone's terribly flawed movie.