News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by Jugurtha on Saturday September 17, 2016 @11:51PM (#12523852)
You're right, but there's more to it. This is a complex issue that when people talk about candidly most often provokes violent reactions.

I give you an example: I live in a country that has suffered a bloody civil war that involved Islamist radicals. After a certain time, there were people from the intelligence community, the military, and eye witnesses that came forward telling that security forces committed acts of violence disguised as Islamist radicals. This is an old recipe (false flag). The rationale is that other states and local population started to worry about the situation and pushed the local government to negotiate, so the armed forces allegedly burned any legitimacy of the Islamist factions committing things that would so badly damage their image, they'd dictate the name of the game.

There was a debate called "Who kills who?" (i.e: who's really committing this?) and the other old recipe was used: calling the people who ask such questions conspirationist and pointing at their tin foil hats (as if nobody ever used false flag tactics and it was impossible for it to have been the case). Whoever even hints that the government had something to do with that would provoke a dismissive reaction and called a traitor for even acknowledging the possibility or failing to assert the impossibility of the government's involvement.

The very act of not climbing on roofs and saying you're against something tags you as a sympathetic and/or a terrorist, even if you're truly against and adopting a neutral posture for the sake of intellectual debate and trying to have a cold, clinical, approach. You're expected to dance and jump and scream to prove you're against terrorism, or you're a terrorist. Similar to the masquerade in the Soviet Union or Nazi Germany, or waving flags to show your patriotism. Gung ho and motto.

Now, I'm not very qualified in these matters and I'm not a Statecraft guru, but the same people who are called terrorists in an armed conflict and are bombed in a certain geographic location (say Syria), are called allies and armed in another geographic location (say Libya). Sometimes some people are terrorist in a location, but other terrorists in the same location aren't considered terrorists. Where do people get the idea that Jabhat Annusra is different from Daech and where do they think Daech comes from? They all have a black flag and it may look the same for most people. Can be confusing.

As the saying goes, "One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter", and it's pertinent it came from the POTUS because if I'm not mistaken, the United States Declaration of Independence is, technically, an act of treason and terrorism against the Crown.

Again, most of the people who'll read that will probably be outraged and think I'm sympathetic or that I don't know what I'm talking about when they've never actually seen a terrorist or been in a terrorist attack. I've outlived half a dozen bombs were on my butt more than I'd have liked (but I had it good, it beats being dead). We've seen what humans are made of inside. I mean "inside" literally. So if there's someone who'd fit the posturing anti-terrorist cliché like a glove, I'd come close. From my experience, though, it's the people who know the least who have the most clear cut opinions on that. It's simple from the outside. They even have more clear cut opinions than the people actively involved, as we speak, in counter-terrorism or intelligence who are more nuanced and think in terms of leverage, positions, weakness, operations, incentives, allegiance, practicality, etc. (This is why many in the Military for instance roll their eyes when they're greeted by too enthusiastic a display of patriotism and "thank you for your service" or just can't understand why on Earth someone is posturing as a tough guy and calling for "killing them all" from the comfort of a sofa).

For the average citizen, a bomb is the end of the world and sets terror. For the entities involved, it's a message. They reason in colder terms that use armed factions as a means to achieve a political goal. States do it to each other, too.

So what's a terrorist? Well, what's a douchebag? For most people, it's someone who doesn't do exactly what we want them to do. For the British, Americans were terrorists. For the U.S., Nelson Mandela was on a terrorist watch list until 2008. What's a terrorist attack? A bomb? Sabotage? Disruption? Killing? All in the playbook of every single Army through covert operations/Intelligence services of every single Nation. These are the things they have covert operations and special forces for. Everyone is a terrorist to someone and all of them think they're the good guys. If you accept that one is true to their cause and think they're justified and that people have different causes, it only makes sense that conflict is bound to happen sooner or later.

Now, this is just one guy on Hacker News who's lived in a country and who could be a terrorist for all we know. But you read books written by U.S. former Intelligence Officers who have decades of experience on the subject. People who know what they're talking about and who've tracked AQ operatives for a long time. They understand the rules of the game. They point out that the discourse politicians have is very far from the truth, but it's the kind of discourse that's easier to sell. Scheuer for instance points out that terrorists attack the U.S. not because they hate freedom, but mostly because of the U.S. foreign policy. Someone can accuse me of knowing jack about this, but the guy who tracked UBL knows at least something about the topic.

We get back to where you're right. The role of Engineers. Engineers are a special breed. I like to joke that if God exists, Engineers are the closest creation to it for he just made an MVP that seriously lacked features (and maybe funding, YC didn't exist back then), and Engineers took it from there.

When the conflict started here, there were a lot of Engineers who took part in it in the start. There were a lot of EE majors, some ChemE and CS majors and they constituted the backbone of the early days. They knew exactly why they were doing it, the stakes, the arguments, etc. It was political and they were the armed branch. Then things got really nasty and the quality of the recruits degraded to the brainwashed who left school in 3rd grade and were in it because, well, they don't know and their recruiter told them there were virgins in paradise (USMC recruiters sell it with sex workers in Thailand to the ones who seem in need. They also sell it for patriotism). I think Engineers got in because they felt they have what it takes to do things.

But here's something funny. Here's an article with an interesting infographic that illustrates the backgrounds of the Intelligence Community in the U.S. pre and post 9/11.

https://news.vice.com/article/doctors-of-doom-what-a-phd-rea...

Do you notice anything interesting?

I haven't read Engineers of Jihad, but Michael Scheuer touches on that in his books and you're saying the same thing: many of these people aren't the ignorant dudes the media make them to be, although their soldiers are for the most part. Many former Intelligence officers direct our attention to why these things are happening.

There's a quote I liked from Mankiw's "Principles of Microeconomics": "People respond to incentives, the rest is commentary".

Here's something interesting to read:

https://20committee.com/2014/09/25/what-if-everything-you-kn...

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by dogma1138 on Sunday September 18, 2016 @11:07AM (#12525577)
>As the saying goes, "One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter", and it's pertinent it came from the POTUS because if I'm not mistaken, the United States Declaration of Independence is, technically, an act of treason and terrorism against the Crown.

No, a terrorist is a terrorist. What ISIS and many other terrorist organizations do in the world are is terrorism, crucify, behead and stone people is terrorism, shooting up nightclubs and blowing up restaurants is terrorism, relativism has no place here. If you ask why Nelson Mandela was on the terrorism watch list well like it or not it was deserved, Mandela wasn't Gandhi (in fact even Gandhi wasn't Gandhi) he had blood on his hands and he supported both political and violent protest of the apartheid regime. Understanding the cause of certain acts does not equate to relativism, support, or acceptance of the reasoning behind them and the people who perpetrated them.

As for your experience I would assume from your name that you are Algerian fits both the name and the overall background of the story of a civil war with heavy involvement islamic terrorist organizations. And while I sympathize with your experience I don't think you have the whole picture either, while you did made some points against basically "arm chair generals" you also fall into the same logical fallacy, living through a conflict rarely provides you with considerable insight into the local and global geopolitics of it.

The Algerian civil war (which technically is still going on to some extent even tho it's even blow LIC signatures currently) was a messy one, there weren't sides, the islamic organizations fought each other as much as they fought the government. Overall the civil war was a good examples of the risks of throwing elections into the pits of new democracies especially those which have large portions of the population with antithetical views to democracy and towards of the ruling party.

As far as the false flag operations I would not go so far and claim that with certainty, Algeria is a case study for many intelligence and military organizations in the world and I've had to study it quite well during my military service.

There were pretty nasty things that have been committed by all sides and plenty of things that you can describe as terrorism both by the "pro-government/socialist/centric" (e.g. the YFA) forces and by the islamic organizations.

But not every bloody act was an act of terrorism, and more importantly when terrorism is evaluated the intent is important, when bomb dropped from a jet drops hits a market by accident that isn't terrorism even if the initial result is the same as driving a mini-van filled with nitrite and gasoline into the same market, the intent behind the act and how you capitalize on are important for making a distinction. Terrorism has a definition which is the use of violence and fear in order to further your political goals, and often unlike it is being described it's not a tool of last resort but the first thing you grab when the situation doesn't go your way.

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by rubberstamp on Sunday September 18, 2016 @12:54PM (#12526007)
just because your idea of gandhi doesn't match gandhi in real life, you cannot just say "even gandhi wasn't gandhi". Mandela and Gandhi were just humans fighting for equal rights for the oppressed. As a programmer, once you think about the rights one enjoys as a white and feels the double standard a non-white experiences trying to have that same right -when you think about it abstractly as rights of humans, anyone who can empathize will feel rage at the double standards that still exists. You have to go back nearly 50 years and think the standards that existed at the time. When I think that way, I think Mandela and Gandhi were incredibly brave. Because Walking the Walk and Talking the Talk is entirely different.

How did the ISIS come into existence. It is the end result of USA and other western countries that tried to arm people to revolt violently against an existing government. That government might be monarchy/dictatorship. But that is no reason for USA to arm people against that government. Those who take up arms are those inherently leaning towards a violent side. Internal politics of other countries shouldn't be meddled with. The people of a country should struggle and push through reforms to a better government. But once violent extremists rooting for the cause has been armed, as the first blood spills there is no reason anymore to both sides. I badly want to beat up all war mongers in the world.

These stupid plans are all treating symptoms instead of treating the root cause of terrorism.

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by dogma1138 on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:17PM (#12526381)
>just because your idea of gandhi doesn't match gandhi in real life, you cannot just say "even gandhi wasn't gandhi". Mandela and Gandhi were just humans fighting for equal rights for the oppressed. As a programmer, once you think about the rights one enjoys as a white and feels the double standard a non-white experiences trying to have that same right -when you think about it abstractly as rights of humans, anyone who can empathize will feel rage at the double standards that still exists. You have to go back nearly 50 years and think the standards that existed at the time. When I think that way, I think Mandela and Gandhi were incredibly brave. Because Walking the Walk and Talking the Talk is entirely different.

I think you misunderstood my point, the point was that even Gandhi wasn't a pure pacifist (not that there is anything wrong with that, it is what it is). Overall there were good reasons why Mandela would be on a terrorist watch list regardless how you feel about him, his ideals, or his actions.

[moral relativism leads to moral bankruptcy]

>How did the ISIS come into existence. It is the end result of USA and other western countries that tried to arm people to revolt violently against an existing government.

That is gross oversimplification of the situation, if you want to talk about root causes then a situational power vacuum isn't a root cause.

>But that is no reason for USA to arm people against that government. Those who take up arms are those inherently leaning towards a violent side. Internal politics of other countries shouldn't be meddled with.

The US did not arm ISIS directly, they did support various other factions in some cases even rival ones.

>Internal politics of other countries shouldn't be meddled with.

Countries meddle in the inner politics of other countries all the time, that's how politics work there are different forms of meddling from statements to actions but everyone meddles this is how the world works. Apartheid fell because of meddling, the Berlin wall fell because of meddling, not every result is positive and not every result is immediately understood.

>The people of a country should struggle and push through reforms to a better government. But once violent extremists rooting for the cause has been armed, as the first blood spills there is no reason anymore to both sides.

You have again gross misconception about "people", "nations" and various other concepts that simply do not exist in major parts of the world.

Nationalism is still in its infancy in the middle east you would find more people in Germany who can recognize the Afghan flag than in Afghanistan. Government and democratic institutions simply do not exist, democracy is more than election, infact elections have nothing to do with democracy they are just a slightly less violent form of conflict resolution and decision making.

Fair courts, transparency, free press, and many other institutions and concepts do not exist, many of these reforms that the people want to push are not "reforms" in any way shape and form as far as modern social democratic value goes.

Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood did quite a bit of "reforms" in Egypt after the election, it didn't however brought the country any closer to democracy. Erdogan is doing a lot of "reforms" in Turkey these days which threaten to pull turkey effectively back 200 years, one can hear the buzzing hum of Kemal Ataturk spinning in this grave from across the bosphorus.

>I badly want to beat up all war mongers in the world.

Isn't that ironic.

Overall what disturbs me the most is the cognitive dissonance that some people have, the west grew to what it is today from the bloodiest period in history, there aren't really shortcuts in life, you can't expect the world to catch up without bloodshed.

Blaming everything on colonialism and foreign policy holds very little water when in fact it's simply the violent birth of nations and peoples, since you can't isolate them because the Truman Show isn't real and you aren't alone on the planet you have to pick sides and try to push them towards better ideals. Violence is part of human nature, warmongering is a red herring.

Also people seem to have pretty short memory, WW2 wasn't that long ago, racial segregation wasn't that long ago, N. Ireland was pretty much yesterday and terrorist attacks across continental Europe were fairly frequent until the late 80's early 90's, people seem to forget the Red Brigades, ASALA, 17N, Abu Nidal and the likes, guess they have worse marketing than ISIS.

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by rubberstamp on Sunday September 18, 2016 @10:27PM (#12528398)
If you think USA is actually trying to bring democracy, then its not me who is naive. Democracy is not the only way. Just because an outsider drew and created a border and calling it a nation doesn't make it a country.

Colonialism was just taking away other people's resources and treating those people like shit while at it. If UK would have created institutions for welfare and development of people and treated them on par with their citizens, then as those people see that as a step closer to better living than as some foreigners that were killing their own, there wouldn't have been any freedom movements and UK would have been biggest country on earth. Am not blaiming anyone. Just trying to point out that nothing good comes out of violence. If we take away the power to kill other person, then eventually they will find a way to live alongside eachother. With a gun you can kill someone in just one second. If there were no gun and no advanced training in killing, then killing becomes messy and bloody and there wont be as many killings.

>You have again gross misconception about "people", "nations" and various other concepts that simply do not exist in major parts of the world.

I do not have any such misconceptions. You can't meddle and force them to live your way at flip of a button. Tribes have their own form of government. Some are good. As long as they are not isolated, they will evolve to better forms of governing. It may take some time, but it eventually they will discover a better form of government and gradually implement it. Take UK for example. They were just normal humans like anyone else. No outsider brought democracy to UK. If it were bought to them forcefully by outsider by overthrowing their king/queen, and throwing away all government structures UK had at that point, and then install someone else as their new head, then UK too would be a bloody mess like libya or syria

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by Jugurtha on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:33PM (#12527097)
>No, a terrorist is a terrorist. What ISIS and many other terrorist organizations do in the world are is terrorism, crucify, behead and stone people is terrorism, shooting up nightclubs and blowing up restaurants is terrorism, relativism has no place here.

Good. What about states that backup these groups? This is basically a high-school where every girl calls the other "slut" for doing exactly what she herself does. If any other state does it, it's terrorism. But if I overthrow regimes, invade sovereign countries with bogus reasons, financing and training militias overseas, etc. it's freedom and democracy.

With which mental mechanism someone could truly think they are righteous doing that, but others are not? One cannot have the luxury of sloppiness here: if you are okay with your Government doing that all over the world, just for the sake of being rational, you have to accept the possibility of retaliation. It doesn't mean you like it. It just means that you understand what's at stake and don't act surprised not knowing why someone is attacking you.

>And while I sympathize with your experience I don't think you have the whole picture either

Never claimed I did, and actually claimed I didn't.

>While you did made some points against basically "arm chair generals" you also fall into the same logical fallacy, living through a conflict rarely provides you with considerable insight into the local and global geopolitics of it.

On the contrary. Sorry I haven't expressed myself very well: I was saying that most people have clear cut opinions about it while being distant. Then said that if there was someone who'd fit the posturing anti-terrorist cliché, I'd come close to that cliché. I meant that I don't buy into thinking I get the whole picture. That was to say that despite being close to the thing, I don't claim to understand everything the way most people who are not close to it seem to think they do. Contrary to what a lot of people post online after a bomb: "OMG! I can't believe it! I was there a year ago" and somehow become subject matter expert just because something happened somewhere they visited a year ago.

>Overall the civil war was a good examples of the risks of throwing elections into the pits of new democracies especially those which have large portions of the population with antithetical views to democracy and towards of the ruling party.

And that is something typical to say. It's a luxury I can afford today, too. Some people said that back in the day. Intellectuals/jurists, etc. "Why not let the Islamists win the elections and we'll win next time?".

The others warned: There will be no next time. The Islamists are telling you explicitly* that the first thing they will do after winning the elections is cancel the constitution ("No constitution, no charter" aiming for whatever they consider "Sharia") and never have an election again and submit everyone to whatever messed up religious views they had.

It's 2016 and it's a nice conversation, but just for the sake of argument: would you really be willing to be so democratic with someone who's telling you exactly what he's going to do and the way he's going to impact your life. They'd probably kill you if you didn't show up at a mosque five times a day, rape your daughter and wife, etc. And you can't oust them or vote.

It is the difficult questions those in Government, as good or bad were they, had to deal with.

This situation was the result of very poor management and a harsh economic context. I remember food lines (for a limited choice of items in number and choice) and rations. I didn't suffer from that really and I can't imagine how the people lived. It was at that time the joke went around that you'd gain more knowing a cashier at a store than a Government official.

The most organized will win the elections. Islamists are known to be extremely well organized. You can see that in Egypt, and you could see it here at that time. They target sensitive domains: education, welfare, religion, health. They gave money to that. Money the government didn't give. There was a void and they filled it.

There was only one political party, the others weren't allowed, but the Islamists maneuvered not as a party but as a hive (from mosques, etc). The Government let them be because they were afraid of the "real" political entities (Socialists, Labor, etc) wanting to become official so they used this to counter that. When the decision was made to finally open up, who had already a shop on the street? Who has been giving away food and helping others all that time? Who had a popular base? Who knows that people will vote for them because they were on the streets every single day? Who was "nice" to people when the Government was absent? It wasn't Islamist radicals who voted. Even people who didn't have anything to do with religion voted just to screw with a Government they didn't like because now they could in a "it couldn't be worse than that" mentality.

It just happened to be the Islamists but it could have been anyone who had that level of organization and done what they did. They'd have the support of the people just for a change of the daily misery. Of course after that everyone showed their true colors and people understood that it in fact could be worse.

>Terrorism has a definition which is the use of violence and fear in order to further your political goals

Isn't that the definition of war?

>and often unlike it is being described it's not a tool of last resort but the first thing you grab when the situation doesn't go your way.

This assumes that the other entity acknowledges your way in the first place, something people almost never do when they have a dominant position. People tend to be nicer when they have an incentive to be, like when they're in a position of weakness or fear, or have more to lose than you.

For the record, I don't claim to be right or something. I'm just asking questions and formulate what seems to make sense and am delighted reading about others' points of views.

Re:Google's plan to deter aspiring ISIS recruits by rubberstamp on Sunday September 18, 2016 @10:49PM (#12528482)
>Good. What about states that backup these groups? This is basically a high-school where every girl calls the other "slut" for doing exactly what she herself does. If any other state does it, it's terrorism. But if I overthrow regimes, invade sovereign countries with bogus reasons, financing and training militias overseas, etc. it's freedom and democracy. With which mental mechanism someone could truly think they are righteous doing that, but others are not? One cannot have the luxury of sloppiness here: if you are okay with your Government doing that all over the world, just for the sake of being rational, you have to accept the possibility of retaliation. It doesn't mean you like it. It just means that you understand what's at stake and don't act surprised not knowing why someone is attacking you.

this was the point i was trying to get to, but pulled myself into some other argument and forgot it. It took many years of reading to see through all the propaganda noise in news to finally get to this conclusion. Me and dad occasionally discuss politics. He doesn't follow international politics much and he still likes obama.