Laws are not meant to lift people from poverty. PEOPLE must lift themselves so far as to lift each other out of poverty. One of the basic functions of government is to protect people from other people (both land and rights). Now, "rights" is where things tend to become grey.
Who should determine what those rights are? The government? People? A majority? San Francisco is an excellent study in what can happen when government plays a role it is not fit to oversee.
Now, Larkin Street is an excellent case study on how the private sector fills in that space governments leaves open when they play around with policy. The aim here is to continue to build these networks around support.
There are numerous examples of people who have done everything society has expected of them but are still unable to find a job. The "all poor people are personally irresponsible" argument is basically a stereotype. Even if it does hold true for >50% of those experiencing poverty, it's pretty cold to tell the minority that actually is sympathetic, "Sorry, you did everything right, but your poverty is still your responsibility and you deserve no assistance from the community which set you up to fail."
> One of the basic functions of government is to protect people from other people
Protecting people from other people sounds like a great way to describe a government-guaranteed lifestyle floor, such as a universal basic income, or some other combination of safety net programs that are aimed at unconditionally ending poverty with no means testing. It would protect you from being coerced by others into the labor market against your will due to the implicit threat of death by the effects of homelessness and/or food insecurity. That protects poor people from other (richer) people pretty effectively.
> Who should determine what those rights are? The government? People? A majority?
I think this is pretty well settled. Public policy is what it is because policymakers we elected set it up that way. So, yeah, basically majority rules.
> San Francisco is an excellent study in what can happen when government plays a role it is not fit to oversee.
I would argue that San Francisco is an excellent study in what can happen when a majority of the electorate is insensitive to poverty and is uninterested in electing representatives who are serious about ending it by passing legislation like UBI or other more comprehensive, non-means tested safety net programs. As a nation, we simply don't prioritize solving this problem with government. We could. We choose not to. Majority rules.
[1] I am almost certain I did not make that argument. Rather, people are responsible for their actions - no one else.
> It's pretty cold to tell the minority that actually is sympathetic
[1] Again, your logic seems flawed here. "You did everything right?" According to whom? The majority? That is a very my myopic viewpoint. Your entire argument proceeds to tell me what I said when in fact, that is clearly not the case.
> Protecting people from other people sounds like a great way to describe a government-guaranteed lifestyle floor, such as a universal basic income, or some other combination of safety net programs that are aimed at unconditionally ending poverty with no means testing...
[1] To be honest, you are making some broad assumptions here. You mention means testing, please explain.
[2] Personally, I feel like you are saying a lot of pretty, flowery things here, but what ("It") would protect you from what exactly?
[3] "Against your will?" Are workers not currently being forced against their will to work? Are Mexican immigrants who flee Mexico to work at the wineries in Southern California not being forced to work against their will?
> because policymakers we elected set it up that way. So, yeah, basically majority rules.
[1] And where do lobbyists fit into this equation? Is it really "public" policy if a majority is deciding what is best for the minority? Doesn't this contradict your argument above: "That protects poor people from other (richer) people pretty effectively." What about liberals from conservatives, right vs left, christians vs muslims, LGBT vs straight, white vs black, etc. You see my point here...it is not the governments responsibility to police people but rather the responsibility of people to police themselves. Yes, there will be outliers, however, we are seeing the ill effects of how public policy BY THE MAJORITY adversely affects all those in the minority.
> I would argue that San Francisco is an excellent study in what can happen when a majority...
[1] Insensitive to poverty? San Francisco is a sanctuary city and as such has laws in place to protect the rights of those who are homeless, illegal, etc.
[2] You can't have it both ways. When you do (as with the case of liberalism) you argue where it makes sense in one context and fail to see how those actions directly impact policy across the board.
[3] In my opinion, it is not a policy problem. It is a problem caused from the US being a welfare state. It pays more to be homeless.
That is true. But not in the way I think you meant it. The majority has made a political choice to implement a much weaker safety net than is needed end poverty. Our safety net full of holes is far from the best we could do.
> It is a problem caused from the US being a welfare state. It pays more to be homeless.
On the contrary. It's a problem caused by not enough welfare state.
People are homeless because programs like Section 8 are underfunded and horribly means-tested. To get public housing you often have to sit on a waiting list. And many people who need public housing can get kicked off the waiting list for a whole range of stupid reasons. More funding and less means-testing would get more people off the streets. Section 8 would be a better program if it was made unconditional, funded at rates which tracked with demand (to prevent waiting lists), or if it were simply replaced by an unconditional basic income.
A similar issue exists for people experiencing food insecurity. SNAP too is means-tested. Many people who qualify don't sign up because they're worried they don't qualify. Others can't get past the paperwork. If the program were universal and unconditional - if everyone had a SNAP card regardless of income, people wouldn't starve.
Those are clear ways in which more welfare state would totally end poverty. But we've made a political choice not to care because the majority of us are insensitive to poverty.
I would like to post and have meaningful conversations with the community and as it stands, I am unable to do so with alanaut.
OP isn't doing both though, and I think that's what JustUhThought is speaking to. OP just said (paraphrasing): "I know people like to talk politics on this subject, but I'm not going to do that, I'm just going to promote private charity."
It is reasonable to argue that we can do both, but just as we expect those talking primarily about political solutions to also highlight how private charity can help in the mean time, we should also expect those talking primarily about private charity to also highlight what political solutions we should also be exploring.
Also I think it's important to remember that some people believe government has no place in solving this problem, so they will promote private charity as an alternative to political solutions.
Likewise there are those who believe that private charity has no place in solving this problem, and the need for private charity represents a failure of public policy, so they will promote political solutions as a replacement for private charity.
So in some senses, we can't do both. The most extreme positions in this debate are mutually exclusive.
So, in LSYS you have a charity that was begun in the neighborhood outside of government programs, which one extreme says shouldn't handle it anyway, which is in turn majority funded by government agencies, which helps the charity to do its work effectively. I'm not sure how this could be a problem for anybody outside of Kristol-Norquistian ghouls.
Are you talking about eradicating homelessness completely? I'm not sure that will ever happen, which is why public services are so important.
There isn't a shortage of people that want to help, there is a shortage of ways for people to get mental health treatment and leave poverty.
There are ~2000 homeless youth (age < 25) in San Francisco on any given night. These young people were often the victims of terrible family situations and have no support network. Larkin Street helps to provide shelter, counseling, education, and anything else they may need to get off the streets for good. More than 70% of the people who "graduate" from Larkin Street leave street life forever.
I know on Hacker News we like to talk about the political causes and solutions to a problem like this. But tomorrow's laws won't change the fact that there are homeless people sleeping on the street every night who need help. Charitable organizations are there to help meet these immediate needs.
[0] - http://larkinstreetyouth.org/