Maybe so, though his main point here is that marathon running is not healthy or in accordance with our evolution. That it takes months' or years' training to become capable of running marathons and that a runner can only undertake a marathon infrequently with lengthy recovery periods in between seems to me to support his thesis.
He also makes the point that as aerobic metabolism/slow twitch movement came after anaerobic metabolism/fast twitch movement, even though we've clearly developed the capability for long-distance running, it's still less fundamental to our nature than brief, high-intensity exertion.
you have to realize that evolution did not select us to reach old age, which means that it misses out on the sort of things we need to prevent aging.
Actually this is the subject area in which De Vany is at his strongest. He's 70+ years old with a body and level of health & fitness enviable to most 20-30 year-olds. See pic at http://www.arthurdevany.com/
I also take issue with his comments on aerobic training and running, since if there is one area where humans are far and away superior to practically all others is long-distance running, which maps properly to the hunting methods of early hunter-gatherers. Seriously, human beings can kill almost any land mammal by tiring them to death.
He also talks about the supposed health benefits observed in professional basketball and football players. Has this guy even SEEN these pro players after retirement? Most of them bulk up weight very quickly and many have substantial lesions from playing. It's a regimen that no one can maintain for more than a few peak years of performance without seriously screwing up your body for good. In contrast, I have met literally hundreds of runners, cyclists, swimmers and triathletes who can still succesfully compete beyond their 50s. Beyond early 30s fast-twitch muscle fiber performance goes down dramatically, but aerobic capacity and slow-twitch fiber keeps up, and for all intents and purposes we depend on slow-twitch muscles and a better lung and cardiac capacity much more than bulk muscle mass.
Finally, just because we consumed a certain diet as hunter-gatherers does not mean that it is the optimal diet, even if it was much better than what we had as early farmers. Nowadays domestic pets live far longer than they do in wild, among other reasons because pet food contains lots of nutrients those animals lack in all-meat diets.
Look, it's all fine and dandy with thinking about evolutionary processes, but you have to realize that evolution did not select us to reach old age, which means that it misses out on the sort of things we need to prevent aging.