News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by chrisseaton on Saturday September 17, 2016 @03:25AM (#12519540)
Most of the people listed in this article aren't politicians, and so can't enact any laws. And even when they are politicians, it looks like they are almost always retired politicians, who can't enact any laws.

Some of them are even counter-establishment figures like satirists and even hackers (in the security sense).

Hillary Clinton is a prominent example, but the article's explanation is that she is invited as a retired secretary of state, as other retired secretaries of state have been, rather than as a current presidential candidate, which seems reasonable.

'it's a great law' doesn't even make sense in your sentence. What's a great law? Bribing people? Bribing people isn't lawful.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:58AM (#12519752)
"Most of the people listed in this article aren't politicians, and so can't enact any laws. "

They are connected individuals who will provide introductions, lobbying and favours for the people paying for the speech.

"but the article's explanation is that she is invited as a retired secretary of state, as other retired secretaries of state have been, rather than as a current presidential candidate, which seems reasonable."

This is really a little naive.

Hillary Clinton is running for Pres with a 70% chance of getting it, her husband is the #1 most connected man in the world.

Over 50% of the private entities she met while Sec of State donated to the Clinton slush fund, to the tune of over $57 million dollars.

It's a form of soft corruption - 100%.

A $250K 'speaking fee' is just another way to transfer money from an org, to a political entity.

A 'donation' to the Clinton Global Initiative is simply a donation to the de-facto Clinton PAC/fund.

It's a form of corruption and it's not a secret. You don't donate to Clinton fund - then get an introduction/favour by Clinton by accident.

I'm singling out Clinton because you did, but it's the same across the board.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by allendoerfer on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:12AM (#12519632)
Only amateurs bribe any more. Professionals negatively bribe: They sponsor the whole show and just stop giving you money once you oppose.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by coldtea on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:50AM (#12519991)
You'd be surprised.

The distinction you make exists, but it's not about amateurs vs professionals, but obviously about those that can afford it (to "sponsor the whole show") and those who don't.

Smaller businesses and interest groups pay their way into laws the traditional bride way all the time.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:16AM (#12519640)
> she is invited as a retired secretary of state, as other retired secretaries of state have been, rather than as a current presidential candidate

Did she leave the part of her that was a future (at the time) presidential candidate at home?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by chrisseaton on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:19AM (#12519653)
> That seems reasonable?

Yes it does to me. If they invite many former secretaries of state it seems reasonable to invite this one. Who cares what she's currently working on if that's not why she was invited? The article even says she hardly mentioned her candidacy.

If you're desperate to get worked up about this I can see where you would find the problem, but I think a charitable interpretation is a former secretary of state was invited to talk like many others were.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:25AM (#12519667)
> a charitable interpretation

Indeed.

If you trust her, you may not see a problem, but if you don't trust her, it's easy to argue this is disguised bribery.

There's a huge difference between a former secretary of state with no prospects of power in the future and someone everyone knew would run for President in a few years.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by hackinthebochs on Saturday September 17, 2016 @11:51AM (#12520985)
Sure its easy to argue if you're not one to need evidence to form opinions, but mere possibilities.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @01:26PM (#12521413)
There's more than enough evidence that she used her influence to help people who gave her money, too much to list here, so here's one extreme example:

> a major Clinton Foundation donor was placed on a sensitive government intelligence advisory board even though he had no obvious experience in the field

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/clinton-donor-sensitive-intel...

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by hackinthebochs on Saturday September 17, 2016 @02:32PM (#12521732)
Yeah I've seen that before. It's really not that interesting. The intelligence board was about nuclear proliferation and they were expanding to include folks with a wider range of skills (rather than just nuclear/political experts). His technology expertise fits what they were after.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @02:58PM (#12521853)
His expertise in high-frequency trading?

How was that related to nuclear proliferation?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by hackinthebochs on Saturday September 17, 2016 @03:11PM (#12521922)
In the technology that enables HFT, sure. And like I said, they were expanding their expertise beyond nuclear proliferation experts. Having experts in other areas is valuable. Surely you're aware that the intersection of networking technology and nuclear concerns is non-empty.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @03:50PM (#12522116)
Is it? Please explain.

And while you're at it, could you also explain why a lawyer, who rose to prominence as Bill Clinton's defense attorney, was the one choosing networking experts for a nuclear proliferation committee?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by hackinthebochs on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:02PM (#12522184)
The point that you seemed to miss was that concerns regarding network availability in the event of a nuclear attack was what prompted the development of the internet. And so networking technology is an important concern when it comes to nuclear issues.

I'm not sure it matters who is doing the choosing. It's rarely an objective process that selects members for committees like this, rather just a matter of who you know and being in the right place at the right time.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @04:33PM (#12522316)
The board's role has nothing to do with preparing the Internet for a nuclear attack.

> The Secretary of State's International Security Advisory Board (ISAB) provides the Department with independent insight and advice on all aspects of arms control, disarmament, nonproliferation, international security, and related aspects of public diplomacy

http://www.state.gov/t/avc/isab/index.htm

Please explain how high frequency trading relates to "arms control, disarmament, nonproliferation, international security, and related aspects of public diplomacy".

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by hackinthebochs on Saturday September 17, 2016 @07:18PM (#12523044)
As I referred to multiple times, they were expanding to include other expertise besides nuclear and political. What about that don't you get? Unless you want to argue that even with this expanded scope he was not qualified, you're just blowing hot air.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @07:25PM (#12523069)
That's the board's description now.

He was appointed in 2011.

I think you just made up this mythical expansion to include other expertise, or you're trusting a cover story someone else invented, because the board's role doesn't seem to have actually expanded.

> Board members are national security experts with scientific, military, diplomatic, and political backgrounds

Strange that they don't mention trading, or networks, or even finance or technology.

But let me give you the benefit of the doubt. If they were looking for his expertise, they must have looked for someone else with that expertise after the scandal. Who did they find instead of him?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @05:02AM (#12519769)
It's a conflict of interest wether you trust her or not.

It's a very thin line, this game.

Clinton should have recused herself from all Clinton Global Initiative issues a long time ago.

The massive Clinton fund with millions in donations from all sorts of political actors, mostly in nefarious places, is worse than Trump's excuses for not releasing his taxes (which he should definitely do).

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @01:12PM (#12521340)
Simple conflicts of interest revealed in a one minute Google search:

A) Matt Lauer, Tom Brokaw, Anderson Cooper, Fareed Zakaria, Katie Couric - and many others - are all members of the press who are supposed to objectively vet candidates, and who will/have moderated political debates, were previously listed as a 'Notable Members' the Clinton Foundation. [1]

B) More than 1/2 of the private entities she met with while Sec of State donated to her Fund - total over $50M. Foreign governments with whom she dealt with directly gave her fund over $170M - this is just the first 1/2 of her term. That's a serious conflict of interest. "Her calendars and emails released as recently as this week describe scores of contacts she (Clinton, as Sec. State) and her top aides (again government officials) had with foundation donors." [2]

C) Clinton put someone on a government board (security related) - who had no experience in the field. [3]

It's a long list.

[1] http://www.mediaite.com/online/flashback-matt-lauer-was-list...

[2] http://www.bigstory.ap.org/article/82df550e1ec646098b434f7d5...

[3] http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/clinton-donor-sensitive-intel...

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @01:39PM (#12521486)
I would invite anyone who down-voted that comment to explain how receiving money (millions of USD) for a personal fund, while at the same time providing government services and favours for donors - as a civil servant - is not a very serious conflict of interest.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @05:00AM (#12519762)
" Who cares what she's currently working on if that's not why she was invited?"

Because if you receive piles of money while running for president, and then pass on favours after getting it, we call that 'bribery'.

I don't want to sound mean spirited, but your position is incredibly naive.

That she is running for president is extremely relevant.

Same for all politicos.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by TrickedOut on Saturday September 17, 2016 @05:50AM (#12519874)
> Same for all politicos.

OK, so why are such articles only written for hillary? Why are you so adamantly opposed to Hillary's practices when it is so incredibly common. How much of all this is about corruption and how much is it about bullying females?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by coldtea on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:55AM (#12520004)
>OK, so why are such articles only written for hillary?

As opposed to who? Trump? Aren't enough negative articles also written for Trump? Besides he is so rich that he doesn't needed "meagre" 250K speeches to influence him -- he probably has voting favors for his business partners and his own business interests pre-planned already.

>Why are you so adamantly opposed to Hillary's practices when it is so incredibly common.

Because even if another 100,000 politicians do it, she's the one who'll be probably sitting in the White House...

You'd rather people prioritize criticizing some second rate senator from Alabama or South Dakota, or the potential next President?

>How much of all this is about corruption and how much is it about bullying females?

The latter none at all? Else we'd see it for other female politicians too.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Saturday September 17, 2016 @07:08AM (#12520034)
Wow that is world-class naiveté. Female politicians of every stripe are bullied daily. This is business as usual for half of our population. And its compounded by guys constantly replying "Hey it isn't happening to me; I don't see it so it must not exist".
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by coldtea on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:30AM (#12520225)
I don't see politicians as male or female and could not care less what sex they are. Are they fit for office is the real question.

Female politicians are just hit with some special charges related to their sex. But male and female politicians are hit with all kinds of shit all the time. Compared to the avalanche of accusations that go to both, having some special accusations because you're a woman politician is not much. Plus, in the current PC climate, most respected outlets don't do that at all -- it's down to the "yellow press" so to speak to do that.

(Besides most, if not all, deserve to be called all kinds of shit anyway, as they are crappy politicians, male or female).

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:49AM (#12520275)
Convenient to ignore the abuse heaped on female politicians (hell any professional) daily. Again, denial that there's a whole special category of female-bashing is not an argument. I recommend reading up on it.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @09:08AM (#12520330)
"Convenient to ignore the abuse heaped on female politicians (hell any professional) daily. "

Get of of HN and back to Jezebel.

The position that females face 'bullying' every day in business and politics is beyond false. It's that kind of rubbish narrative that drives otherwise normal people to vote for a crazy person like Trump.

[dead]
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Saturday September 17, 2016 @11:15AM (#12520810)
I suggest talking to a women in business or politics.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @12:34PM (#12521172)
I have three sisters, two mothers, 3 aunts, a girlfriend (and ex girlfriends), and 6 female cousins - and a 20 year career working in which 50% of my colleagues were females, and several female bosses. Almost all of whom are 'professional women in business'.

You're suggesting that someone commenting on HN hasn't had your amazing experience of 'having spoken to a woman with a job?'?

Again - total and complete rubbish.

Not only are you wrong - you have it upside down: women are far more likely to be 'bullied' by other women in the office, not men. My mother was a VP of customer service, and more than 50% of the time she dealt with extremely petty politics, name calling, shaming, playground antics and other such rubbish among here 90%+ female staff.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Sunday September 18, 2016 @11:30AM (#12525683)
Thanks for the good examples of women being bullied in business! I don't think we're disagreeing here.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @07:49AM (#12520130)
Clinton is being treated far more kindly than Trump.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:51AM (#12520283)
What universe is that happening in? There have been around 50 smoke-screen fake 'scandals' invented around Hillary in particular. None have come to anything. Millions mis-spent in tax money on what amounts to political slander.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @01:22PM (#12521394)
Such as?

Hillary's emails? Potential mishandling of classified information, violations of record keeping laws, and perjury. That's significant, and has nothing to do with her gender.

Which investigation do you think was mere bullying and not about something significant?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @10:53AM (#12539961)
That one, like all the others, was investigated and nothing turned up. To keep repeating those refuted claims is more of the smokescreen. Key word of a smokescreen: "Potential" You can imply something was done wrong with no evidence.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by coldtea on Saturday September 17, 2016 @02:53PM (#12521838)
I think some commenters here talk as Hilary supporters.

I, on the other hand, could not care less for either candidate, I'm not voting there anyway.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:06AM (#12519892)
Because Hillary Clinton:

A) Is running for President B) Is married to an ex-President, and the most influential man in the world. C) Has a $500M slush-fund into which money from nefarious places is being invested - and it's not controlled by campaign spending laws. D) Money was given to her from individuals (more than 50% of them) that she was dealing with as Sec of State - which is a massive conflict of interest on it's own, and she did give many favours that we know about, and it's just the top of the iceberg. E) She was brought up in the article. F) Is probably the highest paid circuit speaker in the world, or was, up until recently.

None of the above is true for anyone else.

That's why.

As far are your 'picking on women' bit ... oh please, this kind of argument makes my skin crawl. Corruption can't hide behind panties, at least outside of campus 'safe zones' where the facts don't matter. 'But she's a girl' is not an argument.

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by tacomonstrous on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:52AM (#12520001)
What is this slush fund? Who gave her money when she was Sec of State? Please substantiate these assertions.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:04AM (#12520173)
The Clinton Foundation is supposed to be a charity but they spend almost nothing on charity - their expenses are 'conferences', trips, meetings - basically Bill and Hillary's personal expense account for things they cannot bill to the government or some other sponsor. Also, they can make ads that promote 'narrative' and the 'personal brand' of Hillary.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by tacomonstrous on Saturday September 17, 2016 @10:45AM (#12520689)
Can you provide evidence for these claims?
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @01:31PM (#12521441)
Ask Haitians what they think of the Clinton Foundation:

> High Hopes for Hillary Clinton, Then Disappointment in Haiti

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/15/us/politics/hillary-clinto...

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by tacomonstrous on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:06PM (#12522739)
Can you point to the part of that article that offers any concrete evidence of wrongdoing?
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Saturday September 17, 2016 @06:29PM (#12522856)
> Fewer than half the jobs promised at the industrial park, built after 366 farmers were evicted from their lands, have materialized. Many millions of dollars earmarked for relief efforts have yet to be spent [six years later]. Mrs. Clinton’s brother Tony Rodham has turned up in business ventures on the island
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by tacomonstrous on Sunday September 18, 2016 @06:25AM (#12524739)
Which of those appears to be concrete proof of wrongdoing to you? Is there any evidence that her brother benefited from the Foundation's actions? All I see are insinuations.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by leereeves on Sunday September 18, 2016 @06:09PM (#12527457)
Millions of dollars donated for Haiti disaster relief weren't spent on disaster relief.

That doesn't seem like wrongdoing to you?

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by tacomonstrous on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:29PM (#12527754)
Not unless it is shown that it was spent on some other expense. Haiti was uniformly difficult for a wide range of charities.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by douche on Saturday September 17, 2016 @07:37AM (#12520101)
The Clinton Foundation is a slush fund. I spent a higher percentage of my income on actual charity than they have in recent years.
Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by saalweachter on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:06AM (#12520177)
You've spent over 88% of your income[1] on charity? That's awesome, keep up the good work!

[1] https://www.charitywatch.org/ratings-and-metrics/bill-hillar...

Re:Why Do Famous People Get Paid $250k to Give a Speech? by jomamaxx on Saturday September 17, 2016 @08:32AM (#12520231)
Ha ha ... the Clinton Foundation is an 'operating foundation' - which means it doesn't give it's money away like other charities. So - if this was like the 'Christian Children's Fund' - than that 88% would be 88% of the money goes to Haiti or wherever, with 12% overhead.

The 'Clinton Fund' doesn't give any money away, the operate their own missions and programs - meaning that - of that 88% , any amount can go to 'consultants' 'lawyers' 'research' 'friends' 'conferences' etc.. And it does. That's a lot of money to spend - and 100% of those people work directly for Clinton Corp..