If you just want to 'set it and forget it', consider its an approach you're taking with the fruits of decades of your life.
[edit: typo]
The Betterment site is pretty, which makes me more inclined to put more money into it more often. This is irrational, but for me this makes it worth more than the 0.15% I end up paying them in fees.
I'm less sure about whether TLH is worth the 0.15% fee, though. The premise is that you do some "equivalent" (to you, but not to the IRS) transactions, report them on your tax return, and lower the taxes you pay today ("basis"). In exchange, you would have to pay those taxes later on your investments when you withdraw them. Is this always the right answer (because those later taxes are in compounded-inflation dollars)? What if I think my tax rate now is lower than the tax rate in ten, twenty, fifty years?
That being said, you won't always benefit from it, and there are caveats you should read about. I've decided to take a slightly more hands on but simpler approach, and have moved all of my investments into a simple 4-fund portfolio at Vanguard.
If and only if you would have done about as well as the robo-advisor in those couple of hours. (I'm not saying this would or wouldn't happen, but it's pretty big for an unstated assumption.)
My point is this portfolio distribution stuff is not an exact science and there really isn't a right answer. There are some broad accepted guidelines, but they are rather broad and simple and you definitely do not need computers to follow them.
Should I also be performing the work of checking several times a year if I should be making sales, recording the losses, buying equivalent securities, and bundling that into a form for the IRS?
Ex: Wealthfront's high risk portfolio back in 2013 had significant exposure to commodities -- mainly oil and metals. That sector has done poorly to say the least, and many a retail investor would not have correctly understood what Wealthfront's definition of risk actually meant.
First of all their fees are too high. Wealthfront's 0.25% fee seems rather small and it is smaller than what a lot of human advisers charge, but if you compute it over a lifetime of savings with the negative compounding effect it will cost you a lot.
Imagine you receive some money when you are 20 from a rich uncle and invest it for 40 years using the wealthfront fee structure. After 40 years you will have paid about 10% of your savings in fees. Or, in other words, you will have about 10% more savings if you had taken a couple of hours to sit down and decide which funds to invest in. Keep in mind that the wealthfront fees are in addition of any etf or mutual fund fees you have to pay to get into investment vehicles.
So yeah, compounding interest is a dangerous thing.
There is another problem with roboadvisers -- people put too much trust in them. In our society there is this implicit trust of the computer, probably bred from multiple sci-fi shows with all-wise computers. Well it is a very dangerous thing when it comes to your savings.
You may not be the best investor, but you should take responsibility in your investment choices. You should know what you are investing in and why. Even if the thing you are investing in is a boring simple S&P 500 fund (as it should be for most of you) you should know what it is and why you are investing in it. You shouldn't just blindly follow some algorithm programmed by god-knows who.