News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by celticninja on Friday September 16, 2016 @03:16PM (#12516547)
Part of me wants to be proven wrong on how strong the EU will negotiate but I understand the reason and need for them to do so and I expect they will. I hate that it is likely that remain supporters will get to say "I told you so' in about 2 years time.
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by sevenless on Friday September 16, 2016 @03:47PM (#12516764)
If the EU really wanted to hurt the UK they'd declare the following things, in increasing order of nastiness:

1. Britain can swap immigrants for retirees. The residency rights of all Britons in Europe are contingent on residency rights of Europeans in Britain. If Europeans are made to apply for visas, so will every one of the millions of Britons in Spain.

2. Drain the country of talent. Recognizing that millions of British are being unilaterally stripped of their EU citizenship, create a new category of general EU citizens, and allow talented British to apply for instant and permanent residence, conditional on (1) giving up British citizenship and (2) learning the language of their continental locale within the next five years.

3. Tell Scotland that it would accept their continuing as a member of the EU if and only if they applied, as an independent state, while the UK was a member state of the EU.

4. Tell the UK that Article 50 is considered to have been invoked as of now, and they have two years to leave.

The last two would be especially funny.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by anexprogrammer on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:00PM (#12516884)
3 would cause remarkably high migration north of the border, some would probably try living in tents. Scots would be complaining of all the bloody English. I know they do that already. :)

4 Fairly sure they can't, or would have by now, just because.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by blibble on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:02PM (#12516910)
since we're into the absurd (3 and 4 are Treaty breaches), here's a satirical list of how the UK could respond to the above, in increasing order of nastiness:

1. The residency rights of all EU citizens in Britain are contingent on residency rights of Britons in the EU.

2. Cut corporation tax to 0% and freeze all contributions to the EU budget with immediate effect

3. Veto everything possible in the Council until exit, and voting against where QMV applies

4. Send half the Royal Navy to the Mediterranean and offer to transport anyone from Northern Africa to the south of Europe, and use the rest to exclude EU ships from British waters

of course once you're at 4 you're basically at war, and then maybe May will press the red button and launch Trident at Brussels

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by notahacker on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:11PM (#12516981)
I think you're overestimating the relative size of the Royal Navy...
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by krona on Friday September 16, 2016 @06:55PM (#12517977)
>> ..maybe May will press the red button and launch Trident at Brussels

Far too expensive; it would be much cheaper to just switch off the Eurobond clearing houses without warning.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by gakada on Friday September 16, 2016 @11:11PM (#12518919)
5. Indefinitely hold up UK's new WTO schedule, apply huge tariffs to UK goods entering the EU, while it doesn't have MFN status.
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by ptaipale on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:40PM (#12517175)
I don't see why Britain would want French or Germans to apply for visas. Hardly a negotiation point.

Regarding point 3, to allow Scotland to join, EU would have to renegotiate the 1998 SGP treaty among all member countries, because Scottish budget deficit is worse than what it has ever been in e.g. Greece. That'd be nowadays probably a harder thing than Brexit itself.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by Normal_gaussian on Friday September 16, 2016 @03:58PM (#12516868)
1 could happen

2 would be interesting but incredibly unlikely

3 would be voted down by the many countries that have non trivial problems with internal divisions

4 can't happen

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by thomasahle on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:43PM (#12517191)
I take it 4 can't happen because the article has to be invoked by the leaving country. However surely there is another article for just kicking a country out of the union?
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by Normal_gaussian on Friday September 16, 2016 @06:37PM (#12517888)
Presumably. However it is not in the interests of the other nations or the beaurocracy to have the UK leave.

The UK is a net contributor to the EU. If the funds it provides are pulled then the other contributors must contribute more or achieve less. The recipients will receive less either way.

The UK leaving weakens the EU significantly. It will also weaken the UK, but make no mistake the best interests of most in power are served by drawing this process out.

On top of that you have to remember that many other nations have severe EU doubts. Key amongst them are France and the Netherlands, two large contributors. An EU collapse could occur if either or both of these leave.

Why would they leave if the UK is kicked out? It's an overtly aggressive move against EU skeptics. Aggressive moves have a long history of causing increased support for the target. Refusing to offer good deals once the UK has left will not be viewed as aggressive.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by volatilitish on Friday September 16, 2016 @03:51PM (#12516785)
I disagree. Leave voters are already being able to say "I told you so".

We haven't had a war yet, we're not in a recession, and the EU is forging ahead with its army, letting Turkey in, etc etc.

I very much doubt the EU will exist in 10 years. It will fall, and our friends around Europe will be free again.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by notahacker on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:13PM (#12516992)
I'm not sure which planet you're living on where Turkey is closer to joining the EU than it was in late June 2016, but it's clearly not ours...
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by sevenless on Friday September 16, 2016 @03:53PM (#12516808)
Nothing has changed yet. In what way are Leave voters able to say "I told you so"?

I very much doubt the UK will exist in 10 years. It will fall, and Scotland will be free again :-)

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by blibble on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:23PM (#12517064)
a crucial point that many have missed is that independence after a hard brexit would likely result in Scots no longer having the automatic right to work in England.

in the previous referendum this wasn't an issue, as the UK and an independent Scotland would both be in the EU together, with the freedom of movement of workers.

your average Scot values the ability to work in England much more highly than the ability to work in the EU, so this makes Scottish independence less likely, not more, which explains Sturgeon's recent behaviour.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by notahacker on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:50PM (#12517241)
Expect it to be a major feature in any second independence referendum campaign.

I suspect if Scotland ever seceded they'd fudge automatic rights to work in England and open borders (in return for border checks at Scottish airports and a customs union) in a similar manner as needs to be negotiated for Northern Ireland. Those negotiations aren't going to be fun...

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by hackbinary on Friday September 16, 2016 @05:28PM (#12517494)
The problem that England has with Scotland is all the land that the English aristocracy 'owns' in Scotland.
Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by Symbiote on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:08PM (#12516959)
> We haven't had a war yet,

A Polish man was killed in Essex, and there's been a huge increase in racist attacks.

> we're not in a recession,

Britain hasn't left yet. But the Bank of England base rate is at a record low.

> and the EU is forging ahead with its army,

:-)

> letting Turkey in, etc etc.

After Erdoğan's response to the failed coup, Turkey is further from joining the EU than it's been for a long time.

Re:EU's Tusk Says May Expects to Start Brexit Talks by February by ptaipale on Friday September 16, 2016 @04:43PM (#12517189)
That's not exactly a war.

A Finnish man was killed by Iraqi asylum seekers a couple of days ago; are we now at war with Iraq? Hardly.