News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by dang on Friday September 16, 2016 @02:14AM (#12512199)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12509741 and marked it off-topic.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by dragonwriter on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:16PM (#12510299)
> why isn't any other medical benefit made free and literally forced upon you like fluoride is???

Iodization of edible salt is commonly either mandated or subsidized by government, so fluoridation of water isn't the only intervention of its kind.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Friday September 16, 2016 @12:47AM (#12511898)
Realized, thank you.

What is the diff between this and other pandemic illness? Meaning (in all seriousness) why certain things and not others? What or who formed these decisions

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by conception on Friday September 16, 2016 @01:26AM (#12512025)
Fortification of cereals and vitamin D in milk as well.
[dead]
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by dragonwriter on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:25PM (#12510356)
> I am literally quoting the head of the largest aluminum processing conglomerate in the WORLD on what he said to my dad.

One part of your post was framed as a quote, the part about "dental benefit BS" and "why isn't any other medical benefit made free and literally forced upon you like fluoride is???" was not.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:30PM (#12510389)
Thats fair...

But the sentiment I have is the same: on the one hand, I quoted some questionable logic from head of alcoa - then I asked a fair question: "if the government is so concerned with my health, why is all other healthcare not free/forced upon me???"

As another user pointed out, Iodized salt is mandated.

How about other medical practices? Why are mammograms not free and forced upon all those with breasts?

Prostate exams?

Lung cancer checks?

Liver issues???

it doesnt matter that its beneficial - what I am asking is "Why these, and not those?"

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by tptacek on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:05PM (#12510598)
How would you "mandate" a prostate exam? You can't exactly secret away a prostate exam in someone's breakfast serial.
[dead]
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by tptacek on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:38PM (#12510772)
I'm Thomas, not Patrick.

We fluoridate because the cost/benefit works out. Mandatory mammograms would have a poor cost/benefit relationship.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:46PM (#12510813)
@tptacek:

That is the second time I have called you Patrick... I have no idea why! I apologize.

My whole life everyone has called me Steve, my name is Sam....

Anyway - I dont know why I see your username and equate it with Patrick. How do I reset mental variables?

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by tptacek on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:50PM (#12510842)
What works for me is closing the screen, putting some headphones on, turning on some music, and going for a walk.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by kanamekun on Friday September 16, 2016 @12:39AM (#12511865)
I do the same thing! Patrick and tptacek have a lot of the same letters in the same order (p-t-c-k)... maybe that's why?
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by auganov on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:18PM (#12510666)
Fortification of cornmeal, grits, rice, and white flour is required by law in the US. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/7/1431c

For more examples of interventions recommended by the WHO take a look at: http://www.who.int/elena/intervention/en/ especially the fortification section.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by jolux on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:06PM (#12510235)
That makes absolutely no sense. They decided to feed it to people as a way of getting rid of it? Why not blast it out into space or bury it in a bunker or any other thousands of easier ways we have to dispose of things than coming up with a conspiracy for having people ingest it?
[dead]
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by betenoire on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:31PM (#12510399)
"And for those that toe the line with dental benefit BS..."

you _did_ say this, i'm not sure why you keep getting defensive when someone replies to your words.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:42PM (#12510468)
Yes I did... Tell my why, irrespective of anything else, that the dental benefits of Fluoride in everything is what we should do?

I am not saying we shouldnt I just want to hear the statement for it... as I do not know. Again, I am just relaying a quote... and I personally have no idea. Also, I'm not "defensive" and I actually find calling someone defensive to be a really lame way of discussing anything.

Don't be defensive when I call you out for beating your wife. Stop resisting.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by DanBC on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:53PM (#12510538)
The many downvotes are asking you to reconsider your aggressive posting style.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:09PM (#12510620)
First I am accused of being defensive... now I am being accused of being aggressive...

WTF?!?!?!

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by tptacek on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:14PM (#12510644)
In case this is helpful: things like "WTF?!?!?!" aren't helping.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:35PM (#12510753)
WTF am I supposed to be helping. Reading comprehension apparently fails this audience.

so yeah. Fuck that. Read a quote. Did I say it no, hence we have the term in english called "quote" - we even have fricken literal characters on our keyboards and in our lexicon called "quotes"

Let me try this for you: "Don't kill the messenger" -- SamStave

Kill me for that.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by jolux on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:05PM (#12510947)
Well the fact that you are diverting discussion of the content of your quote through claiming that quoting it was not an endorsement of its sentiment -- a claim I still find specious at best under these circumstances -- seems to suggest that you are not confident in its validity. Is this the case? Because that's understandable, and we'd get a lot further in this discussion through recognizing it rather than not and continuing to avoid saying whether or not you actually believe what you quoted.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:59PM (#12511190)
So by your logic we automatically believe that someone quoting another means that one is supporting the sentiment or belief in the stated quote?
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by DanBC on Thursday September 15, 2016 @09:15PM (#12511249)
When you accompany the quote with your own words expressing doubt in fluoridation, then yes, people will think you agree with what you're posting. Especially if it's something you keep posting.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by jolux on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:22PM (#12510341)
The question was directed at the speaker of the quote, I was only asking you because I assumed your recapitulation of it meant you believed it. If you didn't, my apologies.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by brazzledazzle on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:56PM (#12510552)
I feel like I'm having de ja vu. Have you brought this up on HN before with similar results? This all feels very familiar.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by DanBC on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:07PM (#12510602)
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by hughes on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:04PM (#12510218)
Maybe you were downvoted because that's totally crazy and cannot generate productive discussion?
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by patrick8 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:23PM (#12510692)
I find it funny that no one yet has called you on your bullshit: Who the fuck is John Haymaker? There was no Haymaker CEO of Alcoa. You quote this person, and you don't even know their first name? Sounds legit.
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:29PM (#12510722)
He was president of ALCOA in the mid-80s -- I cant find him online - but I posted a link to his son's profile page who is an architect. John Haymaker, JR. I also make mention of my dads other best friend: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_S._Herrington who happens to have a wiki page....

So, I dont know what to say about the fact that John SR doesnt have a page about him online as he was head of ALCOA in ~1985...

not my job to prove shit to the internet.... if you dont like my quote - then move on and dont attack me for it.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by patrick8 on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:39PM (#12510779)
Yeah, get bent dude. It sort of is your job to prove who you're quoting or get called out on it. The nearest I can tell is the guy you're talking about is George Haymaker, and if that is who it is, he was CEO of Kaiser, not Alcoa.

But when you do things like this: "FFS; I am relaying a quote I heard from the head of fucking ALCOA! y'all motherfuckers know what ALCOA is? and how far their reach is...."

That detail mattered because you made it matter. No one attacked you for that.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:12PM (#12510981)
Hmm... You may be correct - and I apologize for my failing memory! I was freaking twelve when I heard him say this...

George may be correct - I'll have to ask my dad now.

While people have posted the listed CEOs of ALCOA in the 80s - I know that for certain he was head of ALCOA. My dad built his freaking house and I worked on it with John Haymaker (who my dad was required to employ during the build of his house on the Truckee River in Tahoe so his kid (the one who is now an architect) could get some build experience)...

But I stand by my comment... those statements were made.

Here it is:

"Mr. Haymaker was Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Kaiser Aluminum Corporation from January 1994 through December 1999, and was Non-Executive Chairman of that company from October 2001 until July 2006. Prior to joining Kaiser, he served in executive positions for Alcoa Inc., and Alumax Inc."

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by stanmancan on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:58PM (#12510884)
Not sure who you're thinking of. Maybe it was a weird childhood memory. But based on Alcoa's history page, nobody with that name was the CEO during the 80's.

Alcoa CEO's during the 1980s [1]

W.H. Krome George 1975 - 1983

Charlie Parry 1983 - 1987

Paul O’Neill 1987 - 1999

[1] https://www.alcoa.com/usa/en/alcoa_usa/history.asp

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:14PM (#12510998)
>"Mr. Haymaker was Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Kaiser Aluminum Corporation from January 1994 through December 1999, and was Non-Executive Chairman of that company from October 2001 until July 2006. Prior to joining Kaiser, he served in executive positions for Alcoa Inc., and Alumax Inc."
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by wooster on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:08PM (#12510958)
There is a George T. Haymaker Jr. who "served as an Executive Vice President of Alumax Inc. from 1984 to 1986 and Vice President of International Operations at Alcoa Inc. from 1982 to 1984" [0].

His profile at Genstar Capital includes what seems like a recent photo [1].

Is that who you're thinking of?

[0] http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/people/person.asp?p...

[1] http://www.gencap.com/team/george_haymaker.php

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by Retra on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:35PM (#12510760)
You are being attacked?
Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:16PM (#12511012)
Aggressively debated then :-)

I dont give a shit - but jesus, one quotes another from memory and shitstorm ensues... :)

Whatever.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by fsloth on Friday September 16, 2016 @12:27AM (#12511821)
No one is attacking you personally. A lot of people read HN for insightful or evidence backed commentary and the voting mechanism is there to maintain this quality. No one can quote your story and retain any credibility -to a third party relating your story sounds like this: "A dude in a web discussion forum claimed that a man who, based on his childhood memories, was a CEO at Alcor, said that...". It has degenerated to a gossip - something that is readily available elswhere. High quality diacussion, on the other hand, is hard to come by.

It's okay to relate anecdotal experience - some these type of comments are really good - but the style in the comment should then reflect the fact that the claim cannot be validated in any concrete way.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by samstave on Friday September 16, 2016 @12:36AM (#12511856)
Totally valid statement! I haven't been claiming otherwise.

I proved who I was talking about, I stand by my statement and I believe that some HNers are dicks, period.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by fsloth on Friday September 16, 2016 @01:41AM (#12512071)
"I proved who I was talking about,"

No, you did not 'prove' with any value of proof anyone else here would recognize. None of us can know did that conversation happen, if it did, were they serious or joking,etc etc. There is no way any sensible person could integrate this into their theory of the world.

Basically, unless you can provide evidence that is well known/scientifically rigorous/would hold in the court of law, what you wrote, is hearsay.

You can stand by your statement - no one is claiming you to be a liar. But claiming fluoridation of water is just some nefarious big-corp scheme is, to put it mildy, extraordinary. Given the prevalence of anti-vaxxers and other crazies in the mainstream outlets I can only imagine the toleration level for unscientific gossip on public health matters is really low.

Calm down dude, no need to get personal on people.

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by sporkologist on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:32PM (#12510405)
> we began fluoridation of the water because the only place we can store it is in your liver

"Oh, haha, my attorney is telling me to shut the f* * * up! Sorry about that slip of the tongue."

Re:Show HN: I invented a caffeinated toothpaste by popmystack on Thursday September 15, 2016 @06:36PM (#12510439)
>why isn't any other medical benefit made free and literally forced upon you like fluoride is?

Not only does this not have any merit regarding whether or not we should add fluoride to our public water supplies, but the U.S. government (and many others) quite literally already does this.

We add niacin to flour. We add iodine to salt. We add vitamin D to a litany of food products.

And this quote:

>aluminum production produces fluoride acid - a substance so toxic that we cannot dispose of it... So we began fluoridation of the water because the only place we can store it is in your liver"

Is just completely rubbish. He's basically claiming that we're just walking land fills, using our livers to avoid leaving fluoride acid everywhere.