Re:Microservices
by blowski on Thursday September 15, 2016 @05:40PM
(#12510059)
Interestingly, the Sam Newman book about Microservices specifically says it's easier to succeed by starting with a monolith that you then break up. That advice does seem to be ignored by people who want a microservice architecture because it looks good on their CV, or because they think it will magically solve a bunch of hard problems they don't know how to solve.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microservices
by bunderbunder on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:05PM
(#12511430)
I believe it.
The best place to place a module boundary - and the best format for communication across that boundary - is rarely completely transparent from the outset. With a monolith it's relatively easy (if not actually easy) to fiddle with those details until you get them right. With a service it can be very difficult to iterate on this stuff, so unless you're very confident you'll get it right on the first try, it's best to get a bit of experience in the problem domain first.
I think microservices can work well, but also agree that it's easier to start with a monolith. It's hard to go out and create perfect microservices. In my experience they emerge from the problem much like how an amoeba gets big and breaks off at natural points.