News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber starts self-driving car pickups in Pittsburgh by alanh on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:10PM (#12501235)
Smiling at the underpinning argument that a law cannot exist if it would be impractical to actually enforce.
Re:Uber starts self-driving car pickups in Pittsburgh by gthtjtkt on Thursday September 15, 2016 @10:13AM (#12506273)
I believe "irrational" is the word you're looking for.

If the intersection is wide enough that you can turn while maintaining a safe distance, then what purpose would such a law serve? Why increase congestion for little or no benefit?

Re:Uber starts self-driving car pickups in Pittsburgh by alanh on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:06PM (#12510950)
Once, at 2:30 AM in Arizona, I executed a legal right-on-red via a rolling stop. The streets were empty, and I endangered no one. This is not a contested fact.

But an officer, unidentifiable in the dark some hundred feet behind me, cited me for "not stopping at a red light" due to the fact my vehicle did not come to a complete stop.

Arizona has a state law, named after an unfortunate little girl killed by an asshole who blew through a red light, which makes any "red light violation" an automatic 3 points on your license and applies some certain minimum fine. (8 points triggers a suspension.)

Now despite the fact that there is an entire world of difference between (A) running a red light into cross traffic and (B) performing a California stop at an empty intersection, when I showed up to contest the ticket, the judge mocked me for my suggestion that, as I had endangered no one and not been reckless, I had not violated the spirit of the law and that the ticket should be dismissed. I had to pay the fine and accept the points. State law.

"Irrational" may well be the word I should have used, but it changes nothing. What purpose, indeed, was served by such a strict interpretation of the law?

Re:Uber starts self-driving car pickups in Pittsburgh by gthtjtkt on Friday September 16, 2016 @05:46PM (#12517596)
"And I say to any creature who may be listening, there can be no justice so long as laws are absolute. Even life itself is an exercise in exceptions."

-- Jean-Luc Picard

I agree, a law that serves no purpose shouldn't exist (the only purpose that one served was probably political). That's part of the reason why I find it hard to believe there are laws stating you must wait for pedestrians who are on the far side of the road. I searched but couldn't find them... and since such laws would do little or nothing to enhance safety while significantly increasing congestion (which is dangerous in itself), I think it's reasonable to conclude there are none.

People are probably interpreting the word 'yield' far too generously.