Re:Uber starts self-driving car pickups in Pittsburgh
by SilasX on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:02PM
(#12501191)
>It looks like they had only just entered the crosswalk.
To me it looks like they were fully inside the intersection before the car began the turn, so it was a violation (if very technical and unenforced).
>Sure there's a "letter of the law/intent of the law" distinction here, but I don't see this as a particularly egregious action, especially when compared to normal human behavior (human drivers do this often, and with much narrower margins).
Absolutely -- and as a pedestrian, I would prefer drivers punch through if they have sufficient clearance, rather than pointlessly sit there and watch me walk through.
But there's a difference between
a) "everyone has to do it even though it's not technically allowed", vs
b) "hey, let's showcase this as a prime example of our advanced technology in action"
I think it was wrong to do it as b), since it looks like some elderly people were cut off.
To me it looks like they were fully inside the intersection before the car began the turn, so it was a violation (if very technical and unenforced).
>Sure there's a "letter of the law/intent of the law" distinction here, but I don't see this as a particularly egregious action, especially when compared to normal human behavior (human drivers do this often, and with much narrower margins).
Absolutely -- and as a pedestrian, I would prefer drivers punch through if they have sufficient clearance, rather than pointlessly sit there and watch me walk through.
But there's a difference between
a) "everyone has to do it even though it's not technically allowed", vs
b) "hey, let's showcase this as a prime example of our advanced technology in action"
I think it was wrong to do it as b), since it looks like some elderly people were cut off.