News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by shin_lao on Thursday April 08, 2010 @10:59AM (#1249930)
There are 5 M inhabitants in Finland.

How much do they spend in their education system? Does it scale to a country of, say, 50 M inhabitants?

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by Glide on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:46AM (#1250045)
At the top it says they were behind South Korea in a test score. And South Korea is around 50 million... But South Korea's system is basically studying 24/7. Two very different systems with great results.

Then again South Korea's culture values education highly as well.

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by LargeWu on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:10AM (#1249959)
I don't see how it wouldn't. It's not like if you have 10 times as many students then you'll build a school 10 times as big. You'll instead build 10 times as many schools, all operating more or less independently at roughly the same scale as each other. There might be an additional layer of administration or two, which may cause some inefficiencies in certain areas that may be offset by economies of scale in others.
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by sesqu on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:54AM (#1250074)
Actually, Finland has been shutting down small schools in favor of less bigger ones for a while now, for administrative and financial reasons. So I guess you build three schools three times as big, or something.
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by anamax on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:17AM (#1249977)
> I don't see how it wouldn't.

Let's see if we can think of some reasons.

> There might be an additional layer of administration or two, which may cause some inefficiencies in certain areas that may be offset by economies of scale in others.

How do we know that the two "may" s cancel each other out.

Moving organization-wide decision-making one level further away from the base often has an effect.

Let's put Finland's 5 million in context. Ohio is just over 11M and Los Angeles County is just under 10M.

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by LargeWu on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:47AM (#1250052)
You're right that I don't know that the two would cancel each other out. But even if there is some non-zero effect at work, when you spread it out over all taxpayers, any additional costs/savings are probably trivial.

The main factor at work here seems to be that education is highly valued in Finnish culture, as opposed to the US, where for a large segment of the population, it is not a priority. You can scale processes, but you can't scale culture.

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by anamax on Thursday April 08, 2010 @04:23PM (#1250780)
> But even if there is some non-zero effect at work, when you spread it out over all taxpayers, any additional costs/savings are probably trivial.

I seriously doubt that. Large organizations are qualitatively different from small ones.

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by RyanMcGreal on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:08AM (#1249951)
Why wouldn't it? The per-taxpayer cost ratio would remain the same.
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by yellowbkpk on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:25AM (#1250004)
As the bureaucracy got bigger, wouldn't it cost more? More levels of management, more paperwork, more time spent on oversight.

I don't think the cost/size relationship in any government is linear.

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by hugh3 on Thursday April 08, 2010 @12:35PM (#1250177)
But education isn't handled at the Federal level in the US (and to the extent that it is, it damn well shouldn't be).
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by yellowbkpk on Thursday April 08, 2010 @01:18PM (#1250267)
It's handled at the state level. According to [0], Finland has roughly 600,000 students in what we might call K-12 and according to [1] almost all of our states each have at least as many students individually and most have more than double.

(Not sure what my point was, but it was interesting to find the data :))

[0] http://www.stat.fi/til/opiskt/2007/opiskt_2007_2008-01-25_ti... (Basic comprehensive school education, compulsory education school)

[1] http://www.census.gov/prod/2003pubs/c2kbr-26.pdf (adding elementary and high school columns together for K-12)

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by pchristensen on Thursday April 08, 2010 @01:54PM (#1250356)
Colorado, the 22nd most populous state, has 5M people. Only 9 states have ~10M or more people.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/US_states_by_population

Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by RyanMcGreal on Thursday April 08, 2010 @02:00PM (#1250372)
Unrelated aside: I enjoyed the zero-based index for your references. :)
Re:Why do Finland's schools get the best results? by RyanMcGreal on Thursday April 08, 2010 @11:31AM (#1250017)
Good point. Still, a system an order of magnitude bigger might be only ten percent more expensive per student.