Re:An OS 9 odyssey: Why some Mac users won’t abandon 16-year...
by haroldp on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @01:11PM
(#12490253)
> > Remember all of their one-off, over the top, skeuomorphic apps?
> I actually liked those a lot.
I also liked them, and I think skeuomorphism is a good idea, generally. And I think iOS's completely anti-skeuomorphic abstraction is a bad idea, generally. And I get why Chrome ate my title bar. But is it a good idea for users to have to learn different UI metaphors for every app? I feel like one of classic MacOS's real strengths was that there was ONE UI and users were really skeptical of any app that broke the rules.
> > Anyone else miss WindowShade?
> Oddly enough, I've seen it pop up on Linux desktops for ages.
If memory serves, that feature originally came from Linux/X-Windows, was added to MacOS as an extension first, and then incorporated in the official OS. (And then discarded)
> I actually liked those a lot.
I also liked them, and I think skeuomorphism is a good idea, generally. And I think iOS's completely anti-skeuomorphic abstraction is a bad idea, generally. And I get why Chrome ate my title bar. But is it a good idea for users to have to learn different UI metaphors for every app? I feel like one of classic MacOS's real strengths was that there was ONE UI and users were really skeptical of any app that broke the rules.
> > Anyone else miss WindowShade?
> Oddly enough, I've seen it pop up on Linux desktops for ages.
If memory serves, that feature originally came from Linux/X-Windows, was added to MacOS as an extension first, and then incorporated in the official OS. (And then discarded)