Honestly, I find that IntelliJ isn't anything particularly special. Yet another tool for warezd00dz. It is fadware.
Fadware with plugins. Plugins, upon plugins, upon plugins, upon plugins.
How exactly do you define fadware? My guess is anything you decide to denigrate since there is nothing in the definition of "fad" that applies to IntelliJ, but clearly you may have some other personal esoteric definition in mind and I am curious.
One of the big differences with both NetBeans and Eclipse is that it's commercial software with nice non-paid offerings. But, for example, for my project Community Edition is not an alternative due to lack of JSP editing. NetBeans is great for editing JSP.
Other shortcomings of Community Edition are survivable. In my case this is Google App Engine support that with a lot of manual configuration can be made to run and debug in Community Edition.