But based on the spam race, marketers will then tune content so that it doesn't trip those filters. Paid news and journal articles, etc.
But yes, even here on HN there are problems distinguishing between legitimate articles and paid news.
Also, I wonder if is it possible to detect promotional content by analyzing things like call to actions and such?
Of course what killed directories in the early web is that they had no hope of scaling.
You can have paid news, but it's not doing anything if the mark can't buy the product afterwards because you had to remove all associations with selling to get the news to rank.
Keeping marketing sites high in your SERPs would make you way more money on referrals though.
At the moment for web search it probably would not work, because I imagine from feature extraction to result there are several models involved to create intermediate results.
It would likely be really niche, but it could become the anti-Google, which would be great when people actually seek an alternative to all the noise.
I think it has to be a non-profit like Wikipedia itself, I cannot imagine a model where it can also make money. The submitted site is a candidate but it has to improve the search quality as other commenters pointed out.