Re:A truly decentralised P2P Insurance
by Scirra_Tom on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @04:59AM
(#12486528)
What's stopping someone putting a lot of money on an insurance policy then calling in a fake bomb threat on the plane? Pretty low risk way to make money from anywhere in the world.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A truly decentralised P2P Insurance
by cmussenbr on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @08:15AM
(#12487415)
Interesting discussion!
1. Indeed, we already have many incentives to stop planes by fake threats, and it does not happen.
2. The problem of moral hazard is present in all insurance economies. Of course, this has to be solved.
3. Part of the solution will be a P2P approach, limiting the payout to people who themselves have "skin in the game".
We will elaborate on these topics in the next time (disclaimer: I'm one of the founders of the FlightDelay DApp)
the total amount of payouts per flight is limited as well as premiums and individual payouts. there is a non-negligible legal risk of such action and the payout limits in the end will converge to the price of the risk someone is going to take.
Re:A truly decentralised P2P Insurance
by Scirra_Tom on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @06:45AM
(#12486882)
The legal risk is zero for someone who is out of the jurisdiction of the US completely (eg in some developing country).
Ironically, your system is meant to help compensate people when delays to flights occur yet to me it looks like you've built something that strongly incentivises people to cause more disruption to flights.
Finding the right balance of incentives needs some trial and error. The discussions are not new and well known e.g. with generic prediction markets like Augur or Gnosis.
I think we will find a way to deal with those issues. Experiments like these will help us (and society in general) to come to the right conclusions. Of course we should be careful not to cause too much harm on the way.
Also see https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/529o5p/flightdela... and the discussion there.
also note that there is an easy workaround to limit this which essentially is the difference between a bet and an insurance: check if the user has a valid ticket for the flight.
Re:A truly decentralised P2P Insurance
by Scirra_Tom on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @07:44AM
(#12487158)
I'm not well versed in Ethereum, but this sounds like creep towards the solutions we already have today.