Re:Scalable and secure access with SSH
by otterley on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @11:47AM
(#12489326)
Your premise would make sense if LDAP replication were expensive, but it isn't. LDAP database modifications are relatively rare: you only make them when a new user is added; a user's credentials change; or a user is deleted (which should be never for various post-termination accounting reasons). Even at Facebook, the change rate should be relatively low.
Also you're making an assumption about the need for consistency, when as a practical matter there's rarely a need for it. Caching is effective and practical for this use case and you'd have to make a very strong case that it should be thrown out.
Finally, it is my experience that people grossly misjudge the difficulty of securely and scalably running a CA. Most such comments come from those who have never actually operated one.
Adding extra brittle moving parts like LDAP and linux clustering to a greenfield deployment just doesn't seem attractive when a CA is so easy to run, and you should already have one if you're doing config management sanely.