News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:21PM (#12480997)
America has something like 330 million people in it. I assure you, there are a lot of us who see the basic logic around this and think we should stop worrying about the occasional nipple.

In this particular instance though, it's worse than your complaint. We're talking about censoring an iconic image captured from an important time in our history. I'd be willing to bet that even among the anti-nipple people, this image gets a pass, hands down. Clearly there are some who object, but the vast majority of people understand the message in this image isn't 'enjoy looking at a naked young girl'.

*edit: spelling typo

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by fit2rule on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:26PM (#12481062)
>I assure you, there are a lot of us who see the basic logic around this and think we should stop worrying about the occasional nipple.

I think the basic problem here is not that there aren't Americans who don't have a problem with seeing a bit of nipple, but that a majority of Americans don't seem to understand that if you censor this kind of thing from people, it makes them a lot more reactive to it when they do in fact encounter it - that is to say, by removing from society any acceptance of sex as a positive thing, American society has become far more malleable and reactive to sex - and thus can be sold more things using sex - than it should be.

Sex wouldn't be a billion-dollar industry if nobody was bothered by seeing it now and then.

The same position, by the way, can be taken with regard to the way Americans view their wars. The average American has no clue what it actually means to let their military-industrial complex run rampant across the globe - because they don't see the images, the video, the very real facts of the matter, on the ground. And thus, those who profit from such acts, profit.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:57PM (#12481386)
So far as I know, sex is used to sell the world over. Growing up, I remember there was a fascination with racy European commercials. Depictions of sex are more normalized there, so the ads just get sexier. Sorta like violence in the US.

>with regard to the way Americans view their wars

It's been a long time, but as I recall, the second invasion of Iraq was the most protested war in the history of our country -- before it even started. While we don't see the full brutal detail, we understand perfectly well what it means.

I'd also add that the American military serves as a proxy not just for American interests, but Western interests. We just get to bear the cost and reputation hit for these things. I don't know where you're writing from obviously, but don't be surprised if your own nation / govt has been complicit in, and benefited from American intervention.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by new_hackers on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:59PM (#12481411)
Agree. And at the same time Americans have been inundated with "war" and the pro-Nationalist message that we should always, ALWAYS, 1) support our troops no matter what and 2) never forget.

The fear-mongering is rampant and relentless. And everyone is afraid to question it.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:11PM (#12481537)
To be fair:

1) Leadership should be criticized, particularly political decisions leading to war, but I'd steer away from treating soldiers like shit. In a lot of ways this is punching down. It's mostly people from poorer families that join the military, as some of the benefits are a huge boon to getting out of poverty for them or their children. I don't know if you've ever talked to a recruiter, but...there's some powerful propaganda there for an 18 year old. Once you're signed up, you can't easily leave, and the punishments for disobedience can be severe.

2) Why should you forget? What possible good could that serve? Learn lessons from the past.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by new_hackers on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:36PM (#12482936)
Yes the leadership should be criticized. My point it is a brainwashing tool. My comment probably did not properly convey the nuanced and subtle ways of mind control. It goes more like this when expanded:

"You cannot ever criticize our troops, or our military, because they are heroes. If you do, you are not an American. You must never forget that our troops and our military protect you always."

The tautology is that the actions of our military are always justified.

And this supports the parent comment that the average American has no clue what it actually means to let their military-industrial complex run rampant across the globe, because to question it would be un-American.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:49PM (#12483049)
I would argue that what propaganda that is there is hardly nuanced or subtle, and certainly doesn't qualify as mind control.

I also think a component of it comes from how poorly vets have been treated in the past by the culture at large as well as the government they served. A lot of us have friends and family members that were hard used by their service and more or less cast aside or forgotten about.

For me, the propaganda, and double-think is more around the idea of drumming up support for our troops even though, frankly, we fall pretty short of that. Granted it also gets wrapped up in patriotism, etc., but I think it's a pretty blunt tool in that regard. If anything, you could call it a right-wing version of virtue signalling I guess.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by MichaelGG on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:29PM (#12481725)
Nothing wrong with supporting the troops. Marion Le Pen was questioned on his regarding French military action a long time ago. Her correct response was to point out that the French soldiers did their job, did what they were supposed to. If apologies and shame are appropriate, it needs to be aimed at the leadership.

The attitude towards Vietnam vets was disgusting, right? Drafted people forced into a pointless war. Support the people not the leaders...

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by joesmo on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:11PM (#12482147)
"Nothing wrong with supporting the troops."

That depends on what you mean by "supporting the troops." I actually have no definition or even a clear idea of what this means and I'm certain no one else does either. It's just a generic motto used for brainwashing. Does it mean that I support the individuals not dying? Because if so, then yes, I support the troops very much and I hope none of them die. Does it mean that I support what they do? Fuck no! It's atrocious and criminal. They are murdering and raping people. I would never support that. And of course, it also could mean every single nuance in between. So it's a meaningless saying that seems to exist for the solve purpose of controlling the people who refuse to question basic things. The mere fact that it can mean that I support the troops' actions (murder, rape, and even wasting trillions of dollars of our money) is reason enough for anyone to not "support the troops," and is certainly why I would never utter such an ambiguous and clearly manipulative phrase.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by new_hackers on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:27PM (#12482859)
Exactly, and exactly why it works so well.

If you question "the troops" including why they were sent there to begin with, then you are easily labeled "unpatriotic" and your ideas are immediately dismissed.

It is a very easy way to implement self-culling behavior among the masses. The "powers" do not have to black bag the dissidents, if they are never able to achieve any viable mind-share.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by fapjacks on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:46PM (#12483025)
Nah, just go ahead and criticize. You are going to be fighting an uphill battle, but as someone who spent over a decade criticizing the military while in the military, I can tell you that the bark has no bite, as is often the case with things like this. You'll actually find a lot of people that agree with you, even though they won't add their voice to yours.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:01PM (#12482632)
>They are murdering and raping people.

>I would never utter such an ambiguous and clearly manipulative phrase.

Pick one.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by joesmo on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:12PM (#12483247)
I don't need to. Most of my readers can process more than once sentence at a time.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:00PM (#12483638)
Sorry if the previous response was overly terse, but it seemed easiest to point out what you were doing with your own words. Namely, demonstrating the behavior you're decrying.

Also, how is showing you sentences from different parts of your post being unable to process more than one sentence at a time? If you just wanted to match snark with snark, then fair enough, but as a refutation, it's a bit lacking. Rather, you seem to be making a veiled appeal to authority via having a readership / cult of personality based around you.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by new_hackers on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:29PM (#12482872)
BTW, I am supportive of the troops, and I think that the total cost of war is not calculated. If we are not prepared to shoulder the burden of our military troops after they return, then we did not have the capital to go to war in the first place.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by tdkl on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:39PM (#12481813)
> if you censor this kind of thing from people, it makes them a lot more reactive to it when they do in fact encounter it - that is to say, by removing from society any acceptance of sex as a positive thing, American society has become far more malleable and reactive to sex - and thus can be sold more things using sex - than it should be.

This is brilliant, I've never thought about it this way, but it makes huge sense.

Control of the masses in Edward Bernays style.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by rhino369 on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:27PM (#12482312)
This issue is beyond simple American prudish tendencies. Because America has always been a bit weird about sex, this reaction about sexualizing children is very new. Before the 80s or 90s nobody thought of child nudity as sexual.

This exact photo was on the front page of the NYTimes when it was first taken.

This issue is more about the hyper paranoia about child abuse and child porn. Then again something like 1/8 children are sexually abused. So maybe it's not paranoia if they really are out to get you.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by desdiv on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:52PM (#12483080)
>Because America has always been a bit weird about sex, this reaction about sexualizing children is very new. Before the 80s or 90s nobody thought of child nudity as sexual.

Confusingly enough, child beauty pageants originates from the US, and are mostly still a US-only thing. This contradiction really boggles the mind.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by rhino369 on Monday September 12, 2016 @08:16PM (#12484792)
It's not really a contradiction. We associate child nudity with sexuality because we've started to sexualize children.

It's why America refuses nipples on TV, but we go hog wild for huge tits.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by rahkiin on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:38PM (#12482957)
Can you give a source on the 1/8? I am wondering what counts as 'sexual abuse'. Eg. If a mother or father kissing her or his kid on the mouth is sexual abuse, the number does not surprise me.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:02PM (#12483162)
Maybe depends on where you come from in the US. Where I come from I totally believe it. But then, I am fairly open about my childhood abuse, and it makes other people feel okay about opening up, so I could just hear about an inordinate amount of it.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by tdkl on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:26PM (#12482857)
This seems to be also something that got pushed into mainstream over the world with the widespread of the Internet and probably as a boogeyman term to police it. Also to stop millions of dollars of unpaid tax money in purchase of this merchandise online, which was fine before.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by josu on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:56PM (#12482004)
I recommend this article from NN Taleb: "The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dominance of the Stubborn Minority"

http://fooledbyrandomness.com/minority.pdf

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:42PM (#12482993)
Not all the way through, but just wanted to say thanks for the link. Interesting, and a great summary of how something like the photo in question could get censored. The majority doesn't see it as child pornography, but who's going to fight against the person decrying this as lewd and harmful to children?

Although in this case, the answer might be: Everybody.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by RaleyField on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:14PM (#12482744)
> censoring

Is this really censure though? You'd think it's Facebook applying certain policy mechanically and not Facebook being very pro Vietnam war by trying to curtail others' speech which I would count as censure.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:34PM (#12482905)
Sure it's censure. The motivation doesn't change the act, at least not in this case. I don't think anybody finds Facebook to be taking a stance on the Vietnam War here.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by weberc2 on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:28PM (#12481082)
We're not talking about censoring the image in any meaningful sense; FB told them it was cool if they blurred out the nudity. From FB's perspective, they want to draw a hard line against child nudity so they don't have to deal with the slippery slope between child porn and "art", even though no one thinks this is the former. Personally, I think blurring out the nudity is a pretty reasonable compromise.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by smokeyj on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:38PM (#12481190)
Today Zuck censors for America, tomorrow it's the royal saudi family. This isn't a reasonable compromise. Reasonable is having the offended disconnect their internet and resign from society so they can live in their curated bubble of an existence.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by res0nat0r on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:21PM (#12481640)
Or the folks who don't like Facebook asking them to censor their images could just not use Facebook and post elsewhere...
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by RaleyField on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:35PM (#12482919)
Nobody seems to be thinking that they are forcing Facebook to be an arbiter deciding on when a picture that would be indecent by itself is culturally significant enough to allow showing it. What happens when they misjudge and courts disagree?
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by smokeyj on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:37PM (#12482952)
Agreed. Ideally a diary with a strong lock.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:02PM (#12481444)
I think our definitions of meaningful are significantly different. I try to picture what the image would be like with a girls head atop a blurry body, and it seems to me a totally different thing. Her being naked is a key part of planting the disgust and horror in you that the photographer was aiming for.

Granted, seeing it censored might prompt you to go and look up the original image, prompting you to leave Facebook. So maybe I've changed my mind on the issue :)

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by weberc2 on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:39PM (#12482443)
> Her being naked is a key part of planting the disgust and horror in you that the photographer was aiming for.

What else might pixelation or blurring mean in this context besides that she is naked?

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:04PM (#12482657)
If you're trying to lead me to a specific idea, I'm not following, sorry.

To answer you literally: Serious injury or mutilation, wearing some kind of propaganda the censor didn't want you to see, bawdy tattoos. Probably a million other things, but it would probably still be obvious it was because she was naked.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by weberc2 on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:00PM (#12483635)
Wasn't trying to lead you, I was just wondering if there could be another reasonable conclusion. Your answer seems to be confirming my suspicions.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by r_smart on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:20PM (#12483787)
Maybe, depends on how you did it. Like I initially thought of doing her whole body, but I guess you could just do the parts of her that makes it nudity, so it would be a censorship bikini. That would probably make it more obvious that she was naked, and I'm not really sure what that solves.