News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kinkdr on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:12PM (#12480927)
Lots and lots of people seem to forget: Facebook is an American COMPANY.

It is not a utility, it is not a non-profit organization. People choose to use it, and hence they have to put up with their rules.

If they don't like it, they should stop using it and start using the open alternatives.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by BlackFly on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:34PM (#12481143)
Much like the dichotomy between violence and obscenity which is the subject of the article, the public and private distinction on the ethics of censorship is extremely American.

Consider, a "privately" owned company that opens its doors to the public is absolutely not allowed to refuse to serve someone on the basis of their skin color.

The fact is that when you open your service to the general public then you are no longer strictly speaking a "private" organization: you open yourself up to be regulated by the governments of those people you invite into your service. When you operate what can be argued is very close to a natural monopoly, you have even more duties.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by aikah on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:35PM (#12483891)
> The fact is that when you open your service to the general public then you are no longer strictly speaking a "private" organization:

So Facebook should ban any display of meat cause India, any display or criticism of Islam cause Saudi Arabia, anything related to homosexuality cause Russia ?

Facebook is still a private organization and will continue to censor as it sees fit. The only reason why this idiocy became big is that a prime ministrer from Norway has been censored. That's all. Facebook isn't a democracy.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kj01a on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:29PM (#12481727)
>you open yourself up to be regulated by the governments of those people you invite into your service.

By this logic facebook should also ban gay pride symbols because Russians use facebook...

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kinkdr on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:23PM (#12481659)
Regulation is one solution with a lot of problems.

A much better solution is switching to an open alternative.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by pessimizer on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:00PM (#12482043)
No, a better solution is regulation. A personal solution that can be put into action immediately is switching to an open alternative.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by RaleyField on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:48PM (#12483036)
Unless it's a bad regulation and you a left without a choice because everyone is regulated.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by aikah on Monday September 12, 2016 @05:37PM (#12483910)
Companies shouldn't be regulated for their speech or censorship policies. Enough with regulations. If you disagree with Facebook policies stop using it and use a competing service. Period. Enough with entitlement.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by iThrowA1 on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:56PM (#12485535)
We censor censorship cause censorship is bad
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by FabHK on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:47PM (#12482518)
That (essentially libertarian) defence doesn't hold a lot of water.

Even an American COMPANY is subject to rules, which in turn are designed/evolved to satisfy objectives - they're not immutable natural law.

Even Milton Friedman conceded that government intervention was justified in the case of externalities or natural monopolies. Social networks are, by virtue of the network effect, arguably natural monopolies, and in that sense, could be considered a utility. As such, they might have to be regulated more tightly than ordinary small companies.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kinkdr on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:11PM (#12482717)
I was not trying to defend FB, but rather suggest that people should use open alternatives, as problems like this will always be there with FB.

PS: I just meant to put emphasis on the company, not shout.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by FabHK on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:26PM (#12482852)
Ah ok, fully agree on that people should explore alternatives... (I'm trying to get people on Signal and Wire, instead of Skype/Whatsapp/FacebookMessenger/Viber/...)

As someone has highlighted above, though - there is the coordination problem, that everyone (or at least most people) would have to migrate. (But then - it's happened: Friendster, orkut, ...)

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by RaleyField on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:55PM (#12483120)
It's not like you can't run two social networks concurrently. That's how Facebook replaced its competition, they weren't the first one. And thus far having Facebook account is not really a necessity so why should government intervene?
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by wiz21 on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:06PM (#12483186)
So I guess censorship is not something American companies are forced to avoid. They can use it if they wish (newspapers don't show all the information they haven they regularly hides some of it)
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by larsiusprime on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:25PM (#12481057)
The problem with this view of free speech is that the means of communication are privately owned: http://www.jonas-kyratzes.net/2014/04/26/free-speech-and-the...
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by pixl97 on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:17PM (#12482773)
In the past when talking about free speech, it commonly meant talking on the street corners. Since the roads were public property the government could not censor you there.

What we have occurring in the modern world would be the same if a city sold all of it's roads to a private company and told its citizens their are no longer public spaces.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kinkdr on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:54PM (#12483104)
It is more like people wanting to live in that city because it is hip. They moved there although they knew it is privately owned and they had to put up with the owners rules(which includes in spying on them for his own profit).

I cannot feel any sympathy for them.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by wiz21 on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:13PM (#12483250)
100% agree with you.

If one loves the facebook world, then he has to understand the facebook rules. Ignoring them is a mistake on the user side, not FB.

And it follows that when 99% percent of the billion users will have just ignored the rules, then they will soon understand what it means. So they'll scream and ask governemnt to help them. Then the government will regulate 50% of facebook activities, and well, FB rules will be weakened a bit but officially enforced. People like me will say that society has one more problem, others will say that it's progress... And I'll be sad once again.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by pixl97 on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:02PM (#12483160)
People are more apt to move to a city because there are jobs there. Much like facebook, before its time it was very difficult to communicate with a wide range of people reliably. Facebook gave a way for people to talk, and now they take it away and the peasants grow irritable.
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by wiz21 on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:08PM (#12483206)
They didn't give that. They asked you to agree to their terms of services, eventually gave away some of you personal data in exchange for a, I admit it, practical mean of communication. But thy sure didn't give anything. That's what so many forget...
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by RottenHuman on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:33PM (#12482384)
That might be true, but imagine you phone company or E-Mail provider is ploughing through the content of your messages or even actively filtering your phone calls and is deciding what you can communicate and assumes control over whom you are able to reach.

It might be perfectly legal, you still would not want that to happen and people expressing their concerns should never be shrugged off with the simplistic attitude of "but they are allowed to do that".

A lot of things which are allowed for a company is still not the right thing and should be called out.

Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by wslh on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:38PM (#12481189)
Currently, there are no alternatives to Facebook. Is your mother using Diaspora? Full stop.
[dead]
Re:Facebook is imposing American censorship on the rest of t... by kinkdr on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:17PM (#12482772)
Apologies for the shouting, I just wanted to put emphasis on the company. Maybe asterisks would have been more appropriate.

I think I didn't put my point across very well, I by no means meant to defend FB. My point was really that problems like this will always arise when the people give so much power to a single company. Hence my suggestion to switch to an open alternative.