Yeah, it's exciting that Quake2 runs in Chrome/Safari, it really is. But in 95/96 I was participating in demo-scenes, with graphics that weren't accelerated by the GPU, in 386 real-mode, and it was a lot easier and a lot more exciting (demos that got distributed by a local PC magazine, having as target more people than the people that actually tried that HTML5 Quake2 demo).
So welcome to 1997.
To play on a level field with native apps? No. Wrong discussion! What about for the same sort of tinkerer/hobbyist who wrote Hypercard stacks? Seems to me, with a little hosting and a few tools, Javascript would be dandy!
(And as for commercial apps on Hypercard -- hey, you're free to try. But I'm not talking about targeting those folks.)
My understanding is that there are entire classes of programs where "let's put it on a website" is not a viable method. You can write many types of apps that way, certainly, but you pretty much give up anything so much as pretending to be performance. Additionally, it prevents you from doing anything particularly low-level - if you were desperate enough, you could always set up a web interface to gcc or something, but that won't help you if you want to hack on a device driver or something. Systems programmers are people too, you know. ;)
But if you recall what Hypercard stacks were like, then putting it on a website that's specially tailored to make it easy, combined with a local app to make things more seamless, might actually be a money making proposition.
Put the hacking open/closed politics aside. What do you think about the idea as a business?
But the difference is that HTML5 games are games, and demos from 15 years ago were demos. Writing an entire app like you write a demo is quite difficult; hand-optimized assembly takes a lot longer to write than Java. The improvement over the last 15 years is in the programming language tools and runtimes, not the graphics that the programs produce.
I will say, on Monday that Adobe is releasing flash CS5 which will build native Android/iPhone/iPad/Desktop/Web apps all from the same source (which will be compiled down, not interpreted). I for one would love for this to be the new hypercard :OD
They're just fine with you using their extremely performant javascript implementation.
Search the document for "interpreted code"
They expressly forbid it except for "included interpreters" aka javascript.
So hypercard is out of the running.
The way the agreement is written it expressly forbids interpreters. Additionally, corona is mostly compiled (although parts are still in an intermediate format see 16:30 in http://www.mobileorchard.com/corona-easy-to-implement-high-p...)
Unless you reimplement it in JavaScript
>MonoTouch is delivered as a static compiler that turns .NET executables and libraries into native applications. There is no JIT or interpreter shipped with your application, only native code.
Actually the beauty of this approach, is that a 3rd party could come out with this quickly, using App Engine or Amazon as a back end. Combine that with an iPad App that opens a special purpose browser/Ide to run them in, and I think you'd have a business.