News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by stcredzero on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @02:10PM (#1247968)
Slightly? The account was so moving in its description of supreme, beautiful engineering achievement, I f-in cried -- no joke.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jrockway on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @02:46PM (#1248067)
What's really sad is that 70s-era technology is better than what we have today. No more SR-71. No more Concorde.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by tjic on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:11PM (#1248307)
> What's really sad is that 70s-era technology is better than what we have today. No more SR-71. No more Concorde.

Define "better".

The Concorde was a scam - middle class citizens were taxed by England and France to subsidize a supersonic luxury plane that only the rich could afford to buy (subsidized) tickets on.

The SR-71 was the best tool we could build at the time. Once technology got better, we replaced it with satellites.

The fact that it leaked fuel, flew at Mach 3, had a crew of 2, etc. are not features, they are flaws.

Yeah, it's cool as all heck.

...but don't kid yourself that it's better than what we've got now.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jrockway on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:03PM (#1248564)
The current airlines are subsidized, too. If you want to fly to Small Town, USA, the airline isn't making any money. It's paid for by the people that live in cities that can actually sustain an airport.

The reality is that it takes 6 hours to fly across the Atlantic now. The reality is that 10 years ago, it took half that. That's not progress, even if it is profit.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by pingou on Thursday April 08, 2010 @06:19AM (#1249537)
The Concorde was not a scam, sometimes the state has to subsidize some technology so it could become available.

Think of the moon landing. Not everybody had the chance to be an astronaut on the Apollo mission, but I believe that US citizens were "happy" to pay taxes because they got something to be proud of.

And being french, I'm very proud of the Concorde.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by Hoff on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:17PM (#1248325)
Little that we know about, that is.

Blackbird was black for a very long time.

As for one program that we do know a little (more) about, there's X-37B:

http://www.physorg.com/news189528362.html http://spaceflightnow.com/atlas/av012/100402x37update/

And the X-43D and X-51A Waverider and DARPA FALCON hypersonic aircraft, and various other X planes.

Various known and likely various unknown black UAVs.

And whatever Burt Rutan is up to.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by stcredzero on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @02:49PM (#1248079)
That's kinda true for software too. Symbolics Lisp machines still have features that no other OS/IDEs have.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by rbanffy on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:31PM (#1248215)
Well... At least you can emulate a Symbolics with a PC or, with some luck and effort, on FPGA.

Sadly, you can't do so with a Blackbird or a Concorde...

Oh... And they had no cursor keys.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jf on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:18PM (#1248696)
I spoke with David Schmidt (of symbolics-dks.com) on the phone recently.

Sadly, there is no way to legally emulate a Symbolics machine on a PC. Symbolics' intellectual property is basically in purgatory, the people who own it or have owned it apparently vastly overestimated the value of the IP and refuse to do anything with the IP aside from exchanging it for large sums of money - which nobody is willing to do.

There is a copy of a more recent version of Genera floating around on torrent sites, but from what David Schmidt tells me, it's pretty incomplete.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by saurabh on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:17PM (#1248181)
Please elaborate.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by stcredzero on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:25PM (#1248484)
Example: Anything that printed out something anywhere automatically generated a hyperlink to open an inspector on the underlying objects. No additional coding necessary. The facility was provided through around inheritance in MOP.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jrockway on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:05PM (#1248567)
Right, and now Swank/Slime does this. Not to mention whatever Eclipse does for Java, etc., etc.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jf on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:20PM (#1248703)
As I understand it, with Genera you could inspect that all the way down to the kernel.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by stcredzero on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:30PM (#1248896)
Really? The actual runtime objects? Not the source code of the script, the exe file, or anything hokey like that but first class Objects as in OO and the particular instance that was sent the print message?
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jrockway on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @11:09PM (#1249027)
You're confusing interface and implementation. You can inspect objects and click links to follow the object graph, and you can change the objects as you like while the program is running.

An around modifier, IMO, is a terrible way to implement debugging functionality, because now everything that's not debugging also gets the side-effect that the method modifier adds. This is a better idea: http://common-lisp.net/project/closer/contextl.html

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jrockway on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:04PM (#1248133)
Emacs?
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by stse on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @08:51PM (#1248832)
What makes me sad is the disproportionate amount of money and efforts that the US seem to spend on military projects instead of civilian ones(1). Surly the US did and do great civilian projects, but maybe it's greatest achievements are in space where there's also military motives. While it's European countries and Japan which have developed efficient and high speed civilian transportation.

(1) I mean engineering oriented projects like train, cars, telephone networks etc. not academic research where the US clearly is great.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by ErrantX on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:09PM (#1248150)
Still got the U-2, that's 50's technology right there :)
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by hugh3 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:35PM (#1248378)
Don't forget the B-52, still the core of the USAF's "drop lots of explosive stuff at once" fleet.

That doesn't mean we couldn't make a better B-52 or U-2 right now (and I don't mean a B1 or B2, I mean a big dumb cheap subsonic bomber), it just means that we couldn't make one sufficiently better to be worth the replacement cost. We could also build a better Brooklyn Bridge, but the existing one works just fine for now.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by petewarden on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:32PM (#1248720)
The B52 program was driven by Colonel Pete Warden. He's no relation unfortunately, but its birth was an amazing engineering story:

http://www.boeing.com/defense-space/military/b52-strat/b52_5...

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jfornear on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:52PM (#1248645)
I've heard from former Lockheed engineers that the F-22 outperforms anything we've ever seen -- only that the "official" specs are still classified.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:00PM (#1248655)
I'd give it altitude possibly, but the raptor isn't a speed machine.

Mach 3.5 is a speed attained by two things: Space ships and aircraft built specifically to achieve it. The F-22 is neither, as cool as it is.

While I don't doubt (especially with super-cruise and such) that the Raptor is significantly faster than reported, I'd be very surprised if it is actually Blackbird fast.

I do agree that it "outperforms" anything I've seen, but performance isn't a speed thing alone.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jfornear on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:06PM (#1248665)
You're probably right about the speed records. There really isn't any reason to design aircraft that fast with the satellite technology and weapon systems we have now.

Yeah, sorry for editing my post. I couldn't figure out how to explain what I was trying to say. But said former Lockheed engineers did specifically claim that the F-22 breaks both speed and altitude records. I don't really know what to believe. It does seem smart to release false information about that kind of thing though.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by jackfoxy on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:06PM (#1248139)
...and soon no more space shuttle, or any other way to get people in orbit other than hitching a ride with the Russians or Chinese.
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by tjic on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:19PM (#1248333)
The Space Shuttle is glorious, but it's also an example of how even a bad idea can be made to work if you throw enough cash at it.

Do you know what percent of the weight of the shuttle is cargo?

2%.

It makes zero sense to loft tons (literally. tons.) of ceramic tiles, wings, engines, control surfaces, hydraulics, and more into orbit, just to bring them back down again.

Small capsules with ablative heat shields can ferry astronauts down from orbit for a trivial percentage of the price.

You're looking at all this cool technology and thinking it's a win, but it's not. It's a cost. It raises the cost of spaceflight to the point where you and I will never be able to afford it.

Kill the Space Shuttle and develop something more efficient. It might not stroke the egos of the engineers and the NASA administrators as much, but it will make space more affordable.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by blhack on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:38PM (#1248508)
It also doesn't make sense to spend the ridiculously high amounts of money required to fly things through the air (what are we, birds?) when trains do just fine.

It also doesn't make sense to store all of those files in a mainframe when the filing cabinets do just fine.

It also doesn't make sense to spend the absurd amounts of money required to develop a packet-based communication network when telegraphs and telephones do just fine.

It also doesn't make sense to go to the moon with humans when we can just send a probe there.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:06PM (#1248664)
It also doesn't make sense to spend the ridiculously high amounts of money required to fly things through the air (what are we, birds?) when trains do just fine.

Yes it does, flying is faster.

It also doesn't make sense to store all of those files in a mainframe when the filing cabinets do just fine.

Yes it does, mainframes are smaller.

It also doesn't make sense to spend the absurd amounts of money required to develop a packet-based communication network when telegraphs and telephones do just fine.

Yes it does, PBC is more mobile

It also doesn't make sense to go to the moon with humans when we can just send a probe there.

You're right, this one makes no sense. Kinda like the shuttle.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by blhack on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @08:13PM (#1248775)
Yes it does, flying is faster.

It wasn't at first.

Yes it does, mainframes are smaller.

They weren't at first.

Yes it does, PBC is more mobile

It wasn't at first.

You seem to have completely missed the point. Technology doesn't happen overnight. It's all about costly, seemingly stupid incremental improvements. The shuttle doesn't make sense in its current form, what does make sense is the shuttle as an innovation springboard.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by run4yourlives on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @11:40PM (#1249071)
There is really no reason however to have a space launch platform be reusable. The whole idea behind it is that it was supposed to make things easier and cheaper, and it's done exactly the opposite.

I'm not missing the point at all. You, however have equated every innovation to be progress. Wise people realize that sometimes, despite our good intentions, innovations are sometimes negatives overall, and it's best to take a step back to take two more forward.

In fact, once you get by the "cool" factor of the shuttle, what you end up seeing is that is has in fact been a large step backwards. It has prevented the one nation that could actually dream of furthering space exploration from doing exactly that. The US basically uses the shuttle to do what the first Mercury flights did when we were all watching black and white tv's.

Think back to aviation. The wright brothers used a canard design on the Flyer. While ultimately proven to be safer and more fuel efficient, we needed to have a hundred years of non-canard aerospace development to realize everything between the Flyer and a Eurofighter. Fixating on canard designs may very well have held us in the balsa wood aircraft stage for 10-15 years.

Perhaps, one day, the innovation that is the shuttle will come full circle. That day is not tomorrow though, and no amount of emotional attachment to the idea stops it from being anything but a costly and inefficient nightmare.

(btw, both mainframes and PBC were smaller and more mobile right out of the gate, compared to the status quo.)

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by Zot95 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:12PM (#1248683)
I guess you are trying to be funny, but I don't see the point. Your first 3 points are clearly false (the 4th is not clearly so). Are you suggesting that there is benefit to the pursuit itself? If so, then yes it is good that we developed the shuttle... but why continue to use it?
Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by rbanffy on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:29PM (#1248208)
And both were the most beautiful machines ever built...

It never ceases to sadden me.

Re:The Thrill of Flying the SR-71 Blackbird by barmstrong on Thursday April 08, 2010 @02:23AM (#1249274)
I know what you mean....this is the kind of stuff I want to build at least once before I die. Something that is so good it's in another class and changes the world.