It is a common and somewhat legitimate reaction, to say that geeks just want computer systems to stay geeky so that they have more control and power. However there is a very real non-hobbyist problem with closed systems. I don't think anybody would agree that it was great that Microsoft was able to stymie the growth of the entire internet with their domination of the browser market. And IE / Windows was relatively open, compared to iPhone OS and Safari. The damage done by holding back the growth of the internet has hurt consumers enormously, even though most of them don't know it and couldn't articulate it if they did. Apple is essentially setting the stage for the same thing to happen in the mobile space but far worse since they have quite literally given themselves veto power over any application making it to consumers.
That's a ridiculous strawman and I'm amazed that so many people believe it. Most geeks would be thrilled if more people could perform basic computing functions without constantly asking for help.
Apple is essentially setting the stage for the same thing to happen in the mobile space but far worse since they have quite literally given themselves veto power over any application making it to consumers.
Exactly this. Microsoft was only able to delay the rise of the web; with the power to prohibit disfavored applications they very well might have stopped it completely, or twisted it into a proprietary architecture deliberately dependent on Windows. If Apple has Android shut down in the courts and is able to form a cozy duopoly with Microsoft, we won't be seeing that sort of innovation anymore and we won't even know what we've lost.
I think this is overblown. If Apple gets too high-handed, some Chinese company is going to come out with a cool new platform slick, cheap, and open enough to support the next killer app.
Instead of Hobbyist, perhaps he should have written "non-consumer." Afficianado? Pro-Sumer? Perhaps the slant changes with the term, but the basic idea still stands.
The 13 year olds here have iphones, I bet they don't have a bose sound system in their bedrooms.
More likely an iphone dock with a bunch of speakers attached.
Well said. The hobbyist also won't necessarily like the money making form of it. Does that sound familiar?