Re:Early evidence on “predictive policing” and civil rights
by carapace on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:22PM
(#12482270)
With respect and affection "Human judgement is nothing but a heuristic-driven, semi-conscious probability calculation." is a statement of faith, not an established fact. (How would you establish it?)
Machines don't reason, they compute. It's not the same thing at all. We can reason about things that cannot be represented in any symbolic fashion. Put another way, no machine can tell you: which schools to attend, whether to marry that person, what to have for lunch, the optimal route to work.
Deciding whom to audit is different than deciding how long you should stay in jail.
Probability is not "roll of a die", it is how reasoning actually works. Human judgement is nothing but a heuristic-driven, semi-conscious probability calculation. When you have data that's more quantified than "vague gut feeling", doing things the right, formal, explicit way leads to better results - that's why machines are getting much better at reasoning than humans already.
So if IRS wasn't using probabilistic models to decide whom to audit, I'd say they'd be sucking at their jobs.