News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by jacques_chester on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:08AM (#12473174)
Voluntary voting effectively gives people with a single-issue obsession more power than everyone else, because they show up to vote. In compulsory voting systems, the outliers are moderated by the median, whose concerns are typically less emotional (abortion, guns) and more economic (price of milk, mortgage rates).

Political parties are a concentrated form of voluntary voting. One of the reasons the USA's primaries system is such a caricature factory is because it's a concentrated form of a concentrated form of voluntary voting.

There are many people who propose models like these and don't think through the end game. The end game is that any party where elected representatives have their votes directly controlled by party members is a party that will be instantly stacked by well-organised single-issue whackjobs.

You like crypto? Too bad, the terrorists use it, vote it down. You're OK with gay marriage? Too bad, Jesus is agin it, vote it down.

Techno-utopianism doesn't solve for the fundamental constraint, which is that people will always disagree. No system can create smooth consensus. What is left is to design a safe, functioning system. Direct democracy's historical performance in this respect is abysmal, which is why we have representative democracy instead.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by mbrock on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:32AM (#12473540)
Representative forms of democracy can be implemented on top of direct democracy, no?
Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by ZenoArrow on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:02AM (#12473690)
Yes, you're right, it can. I believe liquid democracy is a good compromise between the two:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fg0_Vhldz-8

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by HairyGing3r on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:41AM (#12473872)
There are a few groups trying to promote liquid democracy utilising a blockchain. I'm really looking forward to see which one will be in the right place and in the right time to grab that Network Effect.

Nice proposal, looking forward what will come of it.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by jacques_chester on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:52AM (#12473922)
Do you mean "having a representative vote mechanically according to the results of another direct vote"?

Sure, for the purposes of argument, you could draw a distinction.

The dynamics will look like direct democracy. With all the troubles there attending.

I imagine it would last until someone helpfully circulated a copy of Burke's Speech to the Electors of Bristol.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by mbrock on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:06PM (#12474689)
I mean delegating one's default vote to a "party" or "representative".

Could you explain why that leads to trouble? I'm not familiar with that speech.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by jacques_chester on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:10PM (#12474707)
> I mean delegating one's default vote to a "party" or "representative".

This is representative democracy, isn't it? I'm confused.

> I'm not familiar with that speech.

It's a short speech and worth reading as one of the clearest explanations of a representative's role: http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch13s7.h...

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by ommunist on Sunday September 11, 2016 @03:11PM (#12475054)
"Direct democracy's historical performance in this respect is abysmal, which is why we have representative democracy instead." <~ I think there have been reasons other than that, which led you to representative democracy. Can you present evidence of the abysmal performance of direct democracy? Well, may be Scandinavian tings do not scale for nations size of the US, but look, Switzerland has direct democracy since 1291, being formalized in the 19th century system of referendums and that works just fine.
Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by jacques_chester on Sunday September 11, 2016 @04:19PM (#12475448)
Swiss direct democracy is rather more constrained than Athens and most of it originates from elected representatives, with an option for citizen-initiated referenda.

California has ballot initiatives, several of which have removed the legislature's powers in some taxes and some spending. Possibly to the detriment of the state, especially since it has dramatically narrowed the tax base.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by abecedarius on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:20PM (#12474413)
> Direct democracy's historical performance in this respect is abysmal

Is that true? It certainly has its critics, but in classical Greece it more than held its own in a highly competitive ecosystem for ~180 years. I'm sure at least that we need more experiments with different institutions.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday September 11, 2016 @03:06PM (#12475029)
Classical Greece is arguably a poor example for reasons outlined elsewhere in this thread.

My argument against is this: professional politicians and bureaucrats often have a hard time governing a nation, what makes anyone believe the aggregate decisions of the crowd would do any better. Admittedly it'd often be hard to do any worse, but make no mistake we are as, and probably more so, fallible and as easily influenced as any politian.

At least with representative democracy we, the crowd, have someone to blame / prosecute / shame / hang. And we probably secretively want that.

I guess I just don't believe that salvation from our own follies can be found in one political system or another. Politics is a shitty abstraction built on top of shitty people like me, what with my unconscious biases, prejudices, and personal preferences. I don't know what's best for other people, he'll I don't even know what's best for me. I mean, I have trouble deciding what to have for dinner let alone what is good economic or environmental policy for the next x period of time.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by riffraff on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:49PM (#12474590)
180 years is not much, other kind of republics fared better (the roman republic lasted 500 years, and the venetian republic more than 1000).

Also, the direct democracy in, e.g. Athens actually encompassed a very limited number of people (adult males owners of land) so it's not 100% comparable with a modern version.

I do agree we should try more things though.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by abecedarius on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:05PM (#12474682)
Owning land was not required. In Pericles's time they did add a requirement that both parents be Athenians, not just the father. I agree that the details and context matter, and there are a lot of details beyond "all the citizens can vote". (Here are some that HN readers ought to find cool: http://www.alamut.com/subj/artiface/deadMedia/agoraMuseum.ht...)
Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by jacques_chester on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:07PM (#12474690)
Classical Greece was a cultural diaspora of politically distinct city-states, which experienced very turbulent politics, swinging between systems of oligarchy, tyranny and democracy.

In fact, the Greek example that is often pointed to as an example of how not to do it. Even by the Greeks, who watched the dynamics up close. See, for example, Plato's fondness for tyranny of him and his buddies over democracy.

Re:A prototype of a decentralized political party by abecedarius on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:54PM (#12474973)
The Greeks had turbulent politics both before and after the democratic period. I'm kind of impressed by the resilience of Athenian democracy.

Plato's a great example of how much better antidemocratic views seem to have survived subsequent transmission. Whenever we read historical judgments instead of facts we need to keep in mind we're seeing what managed to keep getting copied over almost two millennia until the printing press, almost all of the time under ideologies where the prince's word was law.