Re:Facebook Backs Down on Censoring ‘Napalm Girl’ Photo
by legitster on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:24PM
(#12466163)
"We don't keep pictures of naked children on our site." That doesn't seem too simplistic. Especially since censorship for Facebook requires an international staff of thousands to go through every single photo looking for child pornography or gore. How do you train contractors in the Philippines the subtleties between a photo that has historic merit and one that is lewd?
The only reason FB is the "safe" place it is is because they have done an incredibly good and consistent job of getting this type of stuff done. And I don't see any way they run around policies like this without just giving special privileges to ignore the posts of more influential people.
Re:Facebook Backs Down on Censoring ‘Napalm Girl’ Photo
by dragonwriter on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:27PM
(#12466181)
> "We don't keep pictures of naked children on our site." That doesn't seem too simplistic.
The argument over whether it is too simplistic is already all over all the other subthreads, feel free to engage in it there; I don't feel the need to repeat what's been said elsewhere here. In GP, I was just correcting you on what the nature of the complaint is.
They are allowed to. If they weren't allowed to, this wouldn't have happened at all.
OTOH, everyone else is allowed to criticize their particular choices, even while recognizing that they have the right to make choices.
> The only reason Facebook is a platform people choose to use is because of the editorial decisions they have been making.
I disagree that this is the only reason, but even if this was true that wouldn't be an argument against public commentary and criticism regarding Facebook's editorial decisions.
> And the problem was that the policy was too consistent?
No, the problem that has been suggested is that the policy is too simplistic, not too consistent.