Re:DNA analysis reveals there are four distinct giraffe spec...
by dalke on Friday September 09, 2016 @01:38PM
(#12464393)
My definition is: has it been assigned a binomial name? I'll also accept if the process has started.
The PNAS paper for the first event does not give a binomial. It says:
> We treat the endogamous group as an incipient species because it has been reproductively isolated from sympatric G. fortis for three generations and possibly longer.
I was not aware that this was the accepted common definition of a species.
The second also does not give a binomial. It describes a method to "initiate evolution of reproductive isolation among sympatric populations".
Is that enough to say that there is a new species? If so, I was not aware that the threshold for a species definition was so sensitive.
Also don't rely on wikipedia for accurate information about many subjects, it's ok but it's far from perfect or being technically correct.
As for the rest of your argument that's semantics and it clearly misses the conclusion of that article:
"While we can't know the fates of these lineages, directly observing such divergences in real time highlights the fact that we don't always need to look into the distant past or far off future to find examples of speciation in action. Evolution is occurring all around us. We just need to learn where and how to look for it."
We have examples of speciation and divergence in real time over a handful of generations, a species at the end is a group which is capable and practices interbreeding amongst its members but does not breed with others.