Every nation has an inviolable right to defence under international law, and North Korea has explicitly threatened the US, and its allies, continually and belligerently, for years. A country does not have to sit around and wait for its enemies to strike before it acts.
Even Russia, one of North Korea's allies, has warned it that its continued threats of nuclear strikes put it at risk of creating a legal basis for an attack by the US and South Korea: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/08/russia-warns-n...
From your own quote:
> put it at risk of creating a legal basis for an attack by the US and South Korea
Exactly AT RISK. Let's wait until there actually is legal basis first rather than talk about attacking with no legal basis what-so-ever.
But in that scenario the bully is being actively aggressive. I guess to carry on the analogy, what other posters are suggesting is to punch the bully for threatening to beat you up with a baseball bat. First, the bat is not a threat to you yet and second if you do punch the bully you can be pretty sure that unless you knock him out permanently he's going to come back swinging, and his friends will be with him.
In fairness, I did punch my bully in the face in high school and it did effectively get rid of him in my case. But it certainly could have gone differently. And one possible reason it went that way is because my allies were stronger than his (my friends were on the football team and his were potheads). But Russia and China are not weak.
Edit: On the tarmac comment. So? It's politics. You need a thicker skin than that. The best way to handle that is to show you don't give a shit what they think. If you show them that doing something that stupid and petty hurts you it only encourages more. Let them have their laugh and let them push harder if they want. Stay strong. And one day they will either give up or push too hard, and when they push too hard you destroy them. Part of being strong is knowing when to use your strength and when to use restraint.
That is patently false. The United States alone has a long history of successful humanitarian intervention, beginning with Tripoli and running through World Wars I and II. Even within our lifetimes, there was the NATO intervention in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
I believe you may be looking at this through a post 9-11 lens, which is causing you to place too much emphasis on blowback. Obviously Operation AJAX, the alliance with Baathists, and funding of the mujahideen in Afghanistan had significant negative unintended consequences.
However, that is by no means an ironclad rule. For further information I'd suggest A Problem from Hell by Samantha Power and Freedom's Battle by Gary Bass.
I'm not familiar enough with Tripoli to comment on it.
So scratch the word "every" from that statement and replace it with "most"
I'm also don't consider it an intervention when our allies are being attacked and our allies ask explicitly for our help.
Edit: let me make this very crystal clear. I am not a pacifist. I'm a non-interventionists. There is a difference. If we are attacked or there is an imminent threat (I'm talking a battle ships with guns pointed at us right at our or our allies border kind of threat not "credible intelligence" from a "confidential source") we can and should respond with overwhelming force. This is not one of those situations.
Heck, some of the ones on the list are on US soil and many others are rescue missions not aggressions. I think it was implied when I said intervention I was talking about offensive posturing.
Also, that poem is nice and all but I didn't say I don't know what Tripoli is. I said I don't know enough about it to comment on it. I make sure I know what I'm talking about before I write on it.
Edit: From YOUR OWN ARTICLE:
> U.S. demonization of an enemy leader, or military action against him, tends to strengthen rather than weaken his hold on power.
Literally the whole "Common Themes" section of the article you yourself cited speaks about how intervention doesn't work.
You posted a source that defends my point. Thank you.
You are being incredibly naive. The US is the de facto hegemon on Earth. We have been living in Pax Americana for close to 100 years and knew about it for around 70. All pretenses fell around 30 years ago.
When it comes to military power, the US is in a league of its own with one empty league between it and everybody else. The US is an empire (and the mightiest one yet) and will act like that until it isn't capable to do so any more. Historically, that's around 100 more years but I'm not sure history is predictive here.
"Incredibly", eh? Sounds like hyperbole. Also, let's not result to personal attacks shall we?
Right now we are seeing a para-military terrorist group that is a global threat. We have that because the US created a power vacuum that started by intervening in the middle east. Which both Bush AND Obama contributed to. And for that matter the first Bush and Clinton as well. And there is a strong argument to be had that the 9-11 attack was because of prior middle east interventions especially with Israel and Saudi Arabia.
But by all means let's create another vacuum in Asia too that will destroy our ally South Korea and create a vacuum that will probably be filled by China not South Korea as much as we'd like that to be the case.
> We have been living in Pax Americana for close to 100 years and knew about it for around 70. All pretenses fell around 30 years ago.
I'm not sure this is not the point you are actually making so I might actually be agreeing with you. But before we were in this place we didn't assert our power like we do now, yet -- just an observation -- all the sudden we have all these problems. Not to be treasonous but when the "de facto hegemon[sic]" comes into power and the world falls to shit maybe the world and Americans are better off with a more even power balance.
> When it comes to military power, the US is in a league of its own with one empty league between it and everybody else.
Yet somehow we are weak according to many Americans.
Many Americans? Many Americans are dumb as a brick like most people in every other place.
The world falling to shit? How much history have you read? Because the world is better than it has ever been. War activities are at an all-time low.
I won't even start with the middle east. That issue was started at the start of the 20th century. It sort of got solved and then the SU opened it up again.
If you think people hate Americans, you live in America or in one of very few America-hating countries. The US is a very new country with no bad blood running deep. Japan and China? China and Korea? Japan and Korea? India and Pakistan? Iran and Saudi Arabia? Now that is hate.
So it's naive to say that intervention has often negative consequences that are often worse than the problem we're trying to solve when it is demonstrably true? Because that's all I said.
I might even gloss over the naive part. But the fact you put "incredible" in front of it I take exception to and you did it again. I gave you an out yet you doubled down. That is not a positive signal of civil discord.
> Many Americans? Many Americans are dumb as a brick like most people in every other place.
I was disagreeing with those people so I'm OK if you call them dumb as bricks.
> The world falling to shit? How much history have you read? Because the world is better than it has ever been. War activities are at an all-time low.
Mea culpa. I used hyperbole. I apologize. The world has absolutely not fallen to shit in the historical scale. However, I do ask for a citation on the "all time low" part for my own education. And what statistical buckets are you using, all time by year / decade / century?
> If you think people hate Americans, you live in America or in one of very few America-hating countries. The US is a very new country with no bad blood running deep. Japan and China? China and Korea? Japan and Korea? India and Pakistan? Iran and Saudi Arabia? Now that is hate.
Do they have demonstrations in China where they shout "Death to Japan?" The hate might be there but at least the government isn't breading extremist.
Also, hate is such a strong word. I regret using it. Disrespect would be a better one. And I'm not sure "Other countries hate each other" is a good argument. It is giving up. I have hope and think we can do better. If having hope makes me naive than I guess I'm naive and I will take it as a compliment.
> Do they have demonstrations in China where they shout "Death to Japan?" The hate might be there but at least the government isn't breading extremist.
I'm calling B.S on my own statement. There are many times in history where cultural hate has breed terrorist besides our current situation. But I stand by my final statement. Just because other things are messed up does not mean we can't strive for better.
Agreed, but one thing that has been a constant throughout history is that empires eventually become complacent and buckle under their own weight, and have to face smaller contenders that don't have the inertia to maintain the status-quo.
It's telling that there really isn't any empire that has endured "forever", probably because this is simply not possible.
Portugal was the first global empire and ostensibly lasted for 600 years, but its decline started much sooner than it's total lifespan (around the 200 year mark). The country is now a shadow of what it once was, and the US will also be one day.
All the armies of Europe, Asia and Africa combined, with all the treasure of the earth (our own excepted) in their military chest; with a Buonaparte for a commander, could not by force, take a drink from the Ohio, or make a track on the Blue Ridge, in a trial of a thousand years.
At what point then is the approach of danger to be expected? I answer, if it ever reach us, it must spring up amongst us. It cannot come from abroad. If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher.
As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide.
But what is most important is that (most of) the nations are content with this situation. The complete hegemony will probably end soon-ish but the US will probably be the leader for the foreseeable future.
Against NK, which would probably the last "conventional" war in history (unless we started a war with Russia)... we'd be a force to reckon with. After that, though, the state of war today are unconventional forces with unconventional tactics. The US then has a disadvantage. We're too big, too traditional, all we have is a hammer to solve problems, when what we need is a tiny screw driver.
At the very least South Korea needs to be involved. A strike against North Korea will put South Korea immediately into an expensive all out war even if they didn't start it. Second, even if the US military was "still" mighty[1] we would need the blessing of Russia and China or at least their promise not to retaliate and start World War III.
To the person who said...
> There are also credible reports of genocide. That'd be reason enough don't you think?
NO! Many times no! This is one of the reasons the world hates us. We think it is our position to unilaterally police everyone in the world. Everyone should universally decry genocide, absolutely and aggressively. But we are citizens of the world not dictators. We should not be pre-emptively striking. We should not be sending money and weapons to other countries (or at least only send them to one side of the fight for god sake so we don't have two sides fighting each-other with our own weapons!). Every time we have been interventionists either overtly or covertly it has caused unintended consequences and often disastrous ones. When will we learn that it hurts more than helps?
* I say this as a born American.
[1] We spent more on our military than any other country by a huge margin. I really don't understand