Usual election systems already support the case where you find the options unequally unacceptable.
-vs-
"I find any method of death equal unacceptable."
______
Yes, it's true everyone dies, but we're not talking about death and it's obvious that it's possible to have a voting system that's able to tell the difference between indifference, objection, and support of the potential candidates/parties in a general election.
With most voting systems if a single person votes, it's a valid election. If the majority decent, it's still a valid election.
It should be that if the majority decent, the election is nullified - otherwise it's a recipe for a toxic political environment.
"differently unacceptable" is also a terrible situation though! this is the entire point of my argument. I may find some candidates more bad than others. being forced to vote for less bad is still being disenfranchised to a significant extent.
FPTP is a bad system of aggregating preferences where there are more than two options in principle, and produces bad effects in the filtering (and voting) process because people adjust for the bad way that it aggregates preferences. And there are lots of sensible, obvious, and proven ways to make that better. But none of them guarantee you a situation where you aren't forced either to not vote it to vote for a less-bad alternative (though ranked ballots methods move some of the filtering process into the general election, down-ballot votes are still votes.)
the state we find ourselves in this year is abundant evidence of the terrible malfunctioning of the American political process. the system we have in place now struggles to reach even the basic requirements of legitimacy and consent of the governed.
what does popular sovereignty mean anyway if large majorities of the populous are very very very unhappy with their government?