And what makes Airbnb a "brokering service"? Is it the 3% fee collected upfront instead of commissions being billed monthly like Ebay? Therefore, if Airbnb collected money differently to avoid the label of being a brokering "service", would the outrage about discrimination really be avoided? I doubt it.
>direct-by-owner rentals advertised through services that are more listing than brokering services, which do in fact discriminate on axes
What would Airbnb have to change to meet that definition? To me, the homeowners have to create their own listings and upload their own photos. It's not like real estate agents who create listings in the proprietary and closed MLS system on behalf of clients.
(Regardless of your answers, I'm going to ask some Airbnb hosts and see if interacting with Airbnb to them feels more like contracting with broker services or more like an listing an electronic classifieds ad. It's a fascinating psychological angle.)
The fact that they take a commission (rather than, e.g., a size-of-listing-based listing fee, the way newspaper classifieds would), handle rental reservations, cancellations, mediate refund requests, and act as a payment intermediary, etc., all seem to point to them being a person in the rental business providing rental services, rather than a mere listing venue like a newspaper classified or bulletin board.
> Is it the 3% fee collected upfront instead of commissions being billed monthly like Ebay?
No, I can't see that that would be in any way relevant.
> Therefore, if Airbnb collected money differently to avoid the label of being a brokering "service", would the outrage about discrimination really be avoided?
If they changed what they collected money for, sure, but that's not a scheduling thing, its what the basis of payment is and what services they are providing.
> What would Airbnb have to change to meet that definition?
As I see it, they'd need to act as a listing venue rather than a deeply-involved intermediary in the rental transaction. Their fundamental business model, IOW, would have to change.
The core value-added function of a (traditional) rental broker is the matching of renter and landlord. For the renter, brokers recommend which apartments in which neighborhoods are appropriate. For landlords, brokers pre-screen for appropriate renters. With Airbnb, they leave this "matching" as a self-service exercise for both renters and landlords. The prospective renter has to manually browse the listings without the guidance of recommendations and the landlords get no benefit of a human intermediary filtering out inappropriate renters. In other words, Airbnb doesn't even do the main thing that brokers are supposed to do.
You don't have to agree with the above but that's how a lot of people think about rental "broker services".
>handle rental reservations, cancellations, mediate refund requests, and act as a payment intermediary, etc.,
For those who think of broker services in the traditional way, Airbnb is more of a "payment platform" that happens to specialize in rentals rather than a true brokering service.
This is why going after the "broker service" angle would be a weak approach in changing homeowners' minds about discrimination.
I'm not suggesting it as a way to change homeowner's minds, which isn't even something I'm interested in doing [0]. I'm interested in enforcing the existing law prohibiting discrimination. If hosts wish to discriminate, I'd prefer they'd be limited to doing so only in the limited circumstances and manners permitted by law, and not willy-nilly in defiance of the law.
[0] Okay, its something I'm interested in doing, but its a longer-term, less-immediately-critical goal that's pretty much irrelevant to anything I've said about the issues in this thread, except in this footnote.
I understand but your opinion is predicated on your particular reading of the "brokering services"[0] law you cited previously. That extensive enumeration of brokers/agents/salesman/employee is a person that does the matching work on behalf of the client. If other reasonable people don't think Airbnb's "self-service" approach is brokering, then the word "existing" in "existing law" doesn't apply.
Likewise, if one downloads PDFs of legal forms from a website to sell a car or incorporate a business and fills out the form himeself, that website is not providing "attorney services" -- even though many lawyers might download the same PDF files and fill them out for their clients. (Self-service legal forms != attorney services)
Persuading homeowners to not discriminate by convincing them that Airbnb is a real brokering service seems like too big of a mental hurdle to overcome. (No lawyers are issuing dire warnings to homeowners saying Airbnb is a "brokering service". No court rulings have made the headlines saying Airbnb is a brokering service. Etc) Therefore, they see no "existing law" that applies to them.
[0](A) without the use in any manner of the sales or rental facilities or the sales or rental services of any real estate broker, agent, or salesman, or of such facilities or services of any person in the business of selling or renting dwellings, or of any employee or agent of any such broker, agent, salesman, or person and
Well, yes, obviously. I was responding to your claim, which was about the utility of the position as a tool to convincing people about whether they ought to discriminate, and pointing out that that wasn't the point.
> That extensive enumeration of brokers/agents/salesman/employee is a person that does the matching work on behalf of the client.
I've done both sales (on both sides) and rentals (on one side) through brokers, and in no case have they performed matching for me, in every case they provided a variety of administrative support services, including assisting in the search for matches (though, in the present case that I am currently working on, I hope they don't need to even do that -- if things go well, the match we handed them at the outset will be the final one.)
Which is to say that I think your idea of what a broker/agent/salesman or any person in the business of selling or renting dwellings does is excessively and unjustifiably narrow.
It wasn't obvious and your previous statement had to be dissected to clarify it. Upthread, you stated the following without any disclaimers of "in my opinion" or "in my interpretation":
>But its not legal to use a brokering service to arrange the rental if you discriminate, so there goes AirBnB for that use.
It certainly sounded definitive but if left alone without further commentary, it's misleading. That statement depends on how expansively one defines "brokering services". Not everyone agrees with your definition and I further would claim that the majority do not.
>the utility of the position as a tool to convincing people [...], and pointing out that that wasn't the point.
But that is the point. If you want to use an authoritative phrase like "existing law", people have to agree with your intepretation of Airbnb's utility as a "brokering service". If they don't, they believe they still have a legal basis to discriminate.
>I think your idea of what a broker/agent/salesman or any person in the business of selling or renting dwellings does is excessively and unjustifiably narrow.
On the contrary, I think it is your classification of Airbnb as a "brokering service" that is idiosyncratic.
Based on my informal survey of Airbnb renters and landlords, it doesn't seem like the majority agree with you. I ask them "What is Airbnb?" and they say "rental listings" and not "rental brokers".
For people to believe they are breaking the antidiscrimination law because they use brokering services, they need signals from the world such as the states requiring Airbnb to acquire brokerage licenses. (Maybe also add to the process that an Airbnb representative must join the transaction via chat or email to "close" the deal between renter & landlord.) Reading your interpretation of what "brokering service" is not enough.
To recap, the factors you believe Airbnb a brokerage:
- commissions payment
- payment collection, refunds
The factor that Airbnb is not a brokerage: - self-service listings
The "self-service" is a huge mental block and overrides the commissions payment factor in many minds. The sentiment is: "If I do the work to create the listing, why would Airbnb be the broker? That makes no sense."The self-service aspect is why some people think of Christie's and Sotheby's as auction house brokers and they "broker a deal" to sell a piece of art ... but nobody thinks of do-it-yourself Ebay as an auction broker. Ebay is auction listings.
I said "brokering service" rather than "broker" for a reason, as a shorthand for a broad class of services (the exclusion from the fair housing exemption extends to any use of rental or sales services of a broker, agent, or any person in the business or rental or sales; this is much broader than classification as a "broker" specifically.)
> If so, this outcome still wouldn't be realistic: "Well, Ms Smith's loft discriminates against black people but we're all ok with it now because Airbnb collects money differently therefore they are no longer a broker."
It would be perfectly realistic, and is, in fact, the status of lots of small direct-by-owner rentals advertised through services that are more listing than brokering services, which do in fact discriminate on axes that would otherwise be prohibited. Units that do not use brokering services and fit within the size and other requirements of the fair housing exemption in federal law are (under federal law) perfectly legal. (If they don't fall into a state-law exemption, which are often narrower, they may run afoul of state fair housing laws, though.)