1. the assertion there's no actual truffle in white truffle oil 2. that it's pungent and the contestant was pouring it on
I imagine Ramsey is not opposed to truffles, per se, but certainly to fake scents manufactured to smell like truffles and using the flavor to excess.
However, I love finishing white mushroom pizzas with by distributing 10-15 drops of truffle oil on a medium pie. Clearly, it's not the same as shaving truffles, but it actually works well when the oil isn't cooked and it's paired with a combination of fresh and earthy flavors.
(For those who don't know - he plays a caricature of himself on Cutthroat Kitchen, an angry and "evil" version, he grew the beard just for the show. Naturally his normal persona is a food geek.)
What makes you think his Good Eats host character is his "normal persona"? He doesn't play a caricature, just a character.
Jet Tela (judge): truffle oil, man, there's just no place for it in the kitchen.
Alton Brown (host): yes there is. throws the bottle in the garbage.
Harsh.
(I do agree that using truffle oil is a sign of an amateur chef)