Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by tzs on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @03:34PM
(#1245410)
How is it a mistake? In C, if you know how to use it, you know how to declare it, and if you know how to declare it, you know how to use it. I don't see how one can make even a remotely plausible case that doing it otherwise would be an improvement.
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by Dellort on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @03:47PM
(#1245448)
char * (*(** foo[][8])())[]
declare foo as array of array 8 of pointer to pointer to function returning pointer to array of pointer to char
Which do you prefer reading?
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by mcantor on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @04:34PM
(#1245560)
They're both equally illegible to my eyes!
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by tzs on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @07:52PM
(#1245994)
The first, for a couple reasons, but that's not relevant. My point was that I see no advantage or even plausible case for having declaration syntax be different from use syntax.
If C made us declare foo using the second format you gave, we'd still have to write, e.g., ((foo[12][3])())[7] in the code where we are actually trying to use foo.
Can you look at a declaration in the second format, and compare to where the variable is used, and see quickly if the usage is correct? With the current declaration format, it's easy--because declaration and usage use the same format.
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by senki on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @03:57PM
(#1245466)
Why would you write code like this?
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by Dellort on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @04:04PM
(#1245483)
The point is not that, but that as soon as you make slightly nontrivial declarations it is not readable in one pass.
Re:32 years on, K&R's "The C Programming Language" still sta...
by senki on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @04:25PM
(#1245541)
Well, the K&R book talk about the complicated declarations, and recommend the use of the typedef command. Also, it contains a simple program called "dcl", analogous to what you linked.
http://cdecl.org/