You can create content-light pages like the ones Patrick does, for, e.g., encryptedbackupsonline.com--each page on the site would have another title from the same keyword cluster, and each one would end with a call-to-action like "Tarsnap offers [encrypted backups online] for security-conscious power users." (Where the brackets indicate a hyperlink.
Bonus points for having a landing page on your own site that targets those keywords.
(As is probably clear from the above, I do SEO. Patrick's advice is extremely good, so if you have the time, you'll probably do best by just doing what he says. However, if you'd like to know what you might pay to outsource that process to a third party, well, my email address is in the profile.)
(Unless you're talking about doing a reverse proxy to the content of the tarsnap site, but I believe there is also not much advantage to that since the search engines pick up on duplicate content)
[EDIT: this is coming from things I've read not controlled experimentation. I don't think you can be an 'expert' without the latter so maybe I should not have responded]
Right now I have tarsnap.(com|net|org), and I'm wondering if I should consider buying tarsnap<foo>.*, for appropriate values of <foo>, and just making them redirect to tarsnap.com.