[1] http://easacademy.org/trainer-resources/article/intermittent... (see cited sources)
[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25546413
[3] https://health.clevelandclinic.org/2015/10/interested-fastin...
Can you point that one out?
IF is a marginal step in the path of increased health and performance that you should consider, and experiment with, after you've already taken the other, progressively more important steps.
So you're already exercising and maintaining a high level of fitness and athletic output. You're getting good sleep (partly due to the exercise) and meditating. You're eating good, whole foods.
It is in that context that you would then optimize even further - possibly with IF. The question of weight loss strikes me as a bit silly, since by the time you're graduating to IF to eke out marginal increases in health, you're already well past dealing with "weight".
I'm not a doctor but the mechanisms by which the body burns fat is that it has to send the proper signaling at a cellular level. If you listen to the video here starting at 1h03: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PdJFbjWHEU
Though the video is to understand how energy is used and stored for workout reasons it explains a bit the mechanism whereby the body decides to store fat or convert it to phosphates for semi-immediate use.
I'm convinced that intermittent fasting turns off the body fat storage mechanism and turns on the burn fat mechanism. Unfortunately if you only eat less you never send the signals to your body that it needs to stop storing fat. An intermittent fast is therefore way better than just eating less.
For me intermittent fasting means not eating breakfast and eating around 12h30. I've lost 14 pounds this way and I'm finding it really easy to skip a meal now where I couldn't do it without having a headache before.
The only problem is to have good energy levels while dieting/exercising. Because that physical/mental exhaustion is the thing that stops diets. And it's doesn't even need to come from the diet itself, work stress suffices. Just that if the diet adds to total load, then it has to be the first one to go. Being unemployed is not an option.
IF forces you to schedule fewer times to eat, so you eat less. But there are changes to the body when calories are restricted for 16 hour more. Hormonal changes that don't manifest when the body has regular insulin injected into the blood stream.
It's both.
PS: My original thought was it would save a lot of time which it probably did.
Why would it be any different for the "common population"?
>I'll pass on this intermittent fasting "fad" for now!
Fad? It's being around for millennia for.
Because the "common population" does not have half their blood replaced by burning chemicals every week.
>Fad? It's being around for millennia for.
And for millenia, many people thought the Earth was flat, the age of a belief doesn't validate that belief.
I don't follow it, I like my food. However, a cursory glance through other comment on this thread may give you cause to rethink your pov.
And dismiss things just because is against your own assumptions is also far older.
So intermittent fasting also amounts to calorie restriction if you don't binge later.
Everyone's metabolism is different, though. Intermittent fasting can lead to weight loss and avoiding obesity-related problems later. Most people here, being developers or knowledge workers of some kind, probably work late and skip breakfast often, so they do it naturally.
With a "fad" like this, by the time all the research is in 100 years later, it might be too late to try. This is a life decision.
Presumably you've tried it ?
That is to say, starting from a very high baseline of both cardio-vascular fitness and output as well as a high level of muscle training[1] you then tried IF and didn't notice a positive effect in your training or output ?
Fair enough. IANAD and YMMV.
[1] Since you're not going to notice the effects of marginal changes in a loosely coupled, highly variant system anyway. Adding a high flow air filter to your 1997 chrysler minivan probably won't produce noticeable results.
It's amazing how people are prone to experiment with this type of things. They're willing to undergo a very unpleasant experience because it might (unlikely) give them a (slight) health improvement.
If nothing else, the dread of doing a short fast is a pretty decent indicator that you should try it. Being tied to a strict eating schedule is awful.
Fasting can make food taste much better, can focus the mind, might remind people that time if fleeting, or that some people never have enough to eat. People fast for a myriad of complementary reasons.
As opposed to over-eating resulting in a global epidemic of obesity? Which eating habits do you think are the biggest "experiment"?
Observe the conversations around these articles every time they pop up: people think it's unhealthy to go without calories for any amount of time. Where does that come from?
Luckily science has produced good evidence in favor of fasting / calorie restriction that this is slowly changing.
Furthermore, people experiment with all kinds of things for slight health improvements to stay healthy. Working out is not the most pleasant experience when you think about it, but it becomes pleasant because you mentally associate it with something positive and there are traces of euphoria kicking in when it's a pretty intense workout.
Most people work out to lose weight when it's been years I've told anyone who asked me that for weight loss, working out is more tiring and less effective "calorifically" than simply not eating that extra piece of pie. I've seen people want to lose weight, go for a 20 minute run, then come back and down all kinds of food and still hoping/believing/thinking they're going in the right direction for weight loss and they're eating to recover from the effort.
An Olympic swimmer might need 4,000 calories daily. Most of us don't.
https://gravityandlevity.wordpress.com/2009/07/08/your-body-...
and then consider that a slight change in one of the exponents could have a significant effect on a person's quality of life.
As for side effects the only noticeable thing is that on the second night of fast I may sleep much less, but that does not make me sleepy during the day when I break the fast.
This is the most relevant summary: "In both mice and a Phase 1 human clinical trial involving patients receiving chemotherapy, long periods of not eating significantly lowered white blood cell counts. In mice, fasting cycles then “flipped a regenerative switch,” changing the signaling pathways for hematopoietic stem cells, which are responsible for the generation of blood and immune systems, the research showed."
So, mice, and people undergoing chemotherapy. Not exactly (for those who have had friends and relatives ever had to undergo chemotherapy, you will understand what I mean) the common population.
I'll pass on this intermittent fasting "fad" for now!