In telecommunications, common carrier status was a trade: if a telecom treats their network as neutral infrastructure, not discriminating between customers or exercising control over the data that passes over it, they'll be indemnified from legal responsibility for the data that passes over it.
ISPs are attempting to get (and have largely gotten) one half of that understanding without the other half. They want the legal indemnification of common carrier status without the requirements of neutrality that it entails. (The various "safe-harbor" laws passed over the past 20 years, with no strings attached, largely give them that.)
For these reasons, even a lover of property rights and constitutional limits on government like myself can support network neutrality after having familiarized myself with the pro-network-neutrality arguments by people with a track record for good calls in internet design and internet policy and with the history of industries with very strong networks effects, like the railroad, telegraph, telephone, cable and residential-internet-service industries.
And I have to say that the largeness of the number of opinions arrived at with almost no knowledge in this comment section is very depressing.
That is ludicrous.
Could you imagine flying USAIR to a city and when getting to the airport you were under USAIR's restrictions in that city?
Sounds like a crazy analogy until you really think about it.
In addition, how long will these cable monopolies last when we'll be able to erect wireless towers and get internet that way, completely superseding cable carriers?
The Internet was developed with tax-payer dollars. Parts of it are now owned and maintained by various corporations, but the existence of this part of their business is based on public investment.
How is it then that select businesses then get to have exclusive control over what gets passed over certain parts of the 'Net?
I'm not a fan of centralized control nor do I want a nationalized 'Net. I would prefer as a much of a free market approach as possible. But we're well past the point were private companies are going to be inventing and building their own infrastructure, with free and open competition, and arguing for the telcos on the basis of private property or free enterprise seems disingenuous.
The problem here isn't the lack of regulation, it's the lack of competition (as other's have pointed out). No ISP can afford to be shackling their users in the face of unshackled competition.
I hope we'll have a vibrant 4G broadband market in the next 5 years.