I had a laptop hard drive suffer a head crash on the lower platter, and it was able to seek past it. Further, the freezer trick seemed to work a little, but it may have been simply letting the drive rest for a while. I do know that I've never seen it take 12 full hours to reach temperature equilibrium in a hard drive. 3 or 4 usually does the trick just fine. I eventually got most of my important data off. This was before external hard drives were commonplace and frequent backups of laptops made much sense, though.
Re:What To Do When A Hard Drive Fails
by wonginator1221 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @12:23AM
(#1246470)
I have tried the freezer trick before with varying success.
On one occasion, my friend's laptop hard drive kicked the bucket and failed when I tried to use Spinrite.
However, a few weeks ago, a Aeagate hard drive from my brother's Macbook failed. Throwing it in the freezer for a few hours did the trick and we were able to make a full copy of the data.
They used to have 3,4, and even 5 platters. It could just be that he hasn't opened a drive for a decade or two.
That wasn't decades in the past. Western Digital's VelociRaptor 600GB drive has 3 platters. Some of the new 4k sector drives have 3 platters. The first 1TB hard drives (obviously in the past) had 4 or 5 platters.
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/storage/display/1tb-hdd-rou...
Thanks! I personally haven't opened an hdd in 15 years, so I couldn't speak to newer drives. (and now I feel old :) )
Re:What To Do When A Hard Drive Fails
by thaumaturgy on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @01:47PM
(#1245168)
Oh, you're right. I forgot about that.
In the event of an actual head crash, you're usually screwed. If the head crash left a stripe all the way around the platter, the head likely won't seek past it. (I don't know why; it should be able to, but it doesn't -- I tested this recently on a Toshiba drive.)
Head crashes seem to have a tendency to occur close to the spindle, and if that happens, the data on the drive is completely irretrievable.
Occasionally the armature will develop a mechanical fault and will collide with the edge of the platters when the drive powers up. If this happens, you can usually either "adjust" the armature slightly, or replace it with an armature from a matching donor drive.
There are a few other tricks and things too, but those are the most common for internal failures. Sometimes just replacing the logic board is all that's needed -- you have to be able to diagnose what's wrong with the drive. Simply sticking it in the freezer isn't likely to do a darned thing for you.
And I'm a little skeptical that this guy has ever even cracked a drive open. They don't have a "bunch" of platters, they almost always have 2.