News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by tobltobs on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:46AM (#12442899)
I guess it is not using "Facebook" or in your case "Yahoo" in your extension name, but changing the content for a user of a Facebook or Yahoo page is what is triggering the remove of the extension. If it is against the TOS (or Platform Policy) I don't see how else they are supposed to react if the get a complain.
Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by syshum on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:27AM (#12443651)
1. The Developer of such an addon may not have ever agreed to the TOS

2. Google is under no legal obligations to enforce a contract between Facebook and the Facebook user

3. The TOS applies to the user of facebook, not the developer of DOM manipulation Plugin

4. To the extent the developer agree to said TOS, it is largely open to interpretation if TOS have any legal authority at all beyond giving the ablity of platform operators to ban users for violating them. I.e Facebook's recourse would be to identify people using the plugin and then ban them from the site. of-course Facebook has no desire to actually ban anyone for using a public so they use legally dubious trademark claims.

Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by tobltobs on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:21AM (#12451704)
IANAL, but this part from chrome webstore TOS

> You agree that you will not engage in any activity with the Web Store, including the development or publication of Products ... that knowingly violates a third party’s terms of service,

sounds like publishing extensions which enable users to violate the Facebook TOS are not ok.

Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by piyush_soni on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:51AM (#12442932)
It's not the removal of add-on that pissed me off, but the lack of proper response on what would be the acceptable resolution. Not using the name would change the meaning as both of these are not general purpose ad blockers. Had they replied saying "for <their name>" is ok, I wouldn't have removed it. At least they could have replied with a flat 'No' to make things clear.
Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by Merovius on Friday September 09, 2016 @08:11AM (#12461398)
I quote:

> We cannot prevent from being "Flagged" and unable to reveal the reason of flagging.

What do you expect from them? They openly said they can not divulge more information about this. There is no "response on what would be the acceptable resolution" that is more proper, unless you assume they are straight out lying.

Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by barkbro on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:27AM (#12443644)
I don't see how an add-on posted on the Chrome store is subject to Facebook's ToS. It might be aiding people in breaking the ToS, but is there really a law against that?
Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by aminorex on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @11:25AM (#12444155)
Google makes the laws now. Governments are mostly irrelevant.
Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by SZJX on Friday September 09, 2016 @01:05PM (#12464083)
Well you've been quite extreme in this thread. I get your concerns, but I'd say that day is still very much far away. Libertarian lunatics like Peter Thiel certainly dream of it, but I really doubt it will become the reality, at least not over the whole world if indeed so in the already very corporate America.

Anyways, if the vision aspired by Thiel happens, those "libertarian" capitalists will be killed by revolts/uprisings in an instant. A world without tax nor regulation nor basic support for social equality never works. Just as explained in Capitalism in the 21st Century, if inequality is not addressed, there will be revolts and chaos. Extreme injustice can't dominate forever.

Re:How Google obliterated my 4 year old Chrome extension fea... by tobltobs on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:24AM (#12451716)
There is no law necessary, Google explicitly forbids publishing extensions that aide people in violating the TOS of third party services.