News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inclusivity Is a Joke by tootie on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:24PM (#12425886)
I'll go ahead and jump down your throat for saying something really stupid. For one thing, no speech is banned. Wild hyperbole doesn't help your argument. Crockford can say whatever the fuck he wants. He has no inalienable right to be invited to private conferences. Secondly, this was just a poor attempt at placating people against some seemingly misplaced umbrage. This was a mistake. If you think this somehow sinks the entire mission of treating people fairly, you are simply wrong. Inclusivity and diversity are great. Treating people with respect is great. Respecting complaints of abusive behavior is great. Placating whiners is not. Striking the balance is not easy and some attempts will miss the mark. That doesn't mean you give up.
Re:Inclusivity Is a Joke by coldtea on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:55PM (#12426066)
>I'll go ahead and jump down your throat for saying something really stupid. For one thing, no speech is banned.

Perhaps you mean "no speech is totally banned". Because it sure as hell it IS banned from being part of the conference.

>Crockford can say whatever the fuck he wants.

Nobody said they established their own dictatorship across the country and prevented him from speaking everywhere, so this "correction" is beside the point.

He is totally not allowed to say what he wants as part of his presentation, because it was cancelled. And that was because some people couldn't accept him saying some things elsewhere either.

What if someone takes offence of your "whatever the fuck he wants" line as sexist? Should you be thrown our from HN?

You'd still be able to say "whatever you want" elsewhere, so no harm, right?

Re:Inclusivity Is a Joke by LyndsySimon on Monday September 05, 2016 @11:29AM (#12430803)
> Perhaps you mean "no speech is totally banned". Because it sure as hell it IS banned from being part of the conference.

That's the problem though, isn't it?

It's clear from Nodevember's statement[1] that the action was taken because some member of the community felt uncomfortable, and explicitly not because of any specific speech or action on the part of Mr. Crockford.

If this were a movement to censor certain specific speech, I would likely be opposed to it on philosophical grounds but would support and empathize with the motivation. That's not what this movement is about. I see this as an example of a movement based on an extreme political ideology usurping power within a community by shaming its members into submission.

[1] http://nodevember.org/statement.html

Re:Inclusivity Is a Joke by mzw_mzw on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @02:30AM (#12433977)
"For one thing, no speech is banned"

For the million, billionth time, this not about speech being banned. It has never been about speech being banned. Stop talking as if people are claiming his speech was banned.