Yes they are. Life expectancy changes from median sugar intake are negligible.
> There has been an enormous rise in diabetes and obesity, including in children.
People have been eating a ton of sugar since the British started colonizing sugar cane producers. The rise in diabetes and obesity coincides with improving nutritional access. As people eat more, they get fatter. Big surprise. The solution is not to tax the shit out of food.
> there are enormous costs imposed on the health system.
So internalize those externalities and make people pay for their own health care.
I agree that if everyone else is on the hook for your medical bills, they have a say over what you ingest. This, of course, is why I'm against everyone being on the hook for everyone else's medical bills...
This is entirely preventable with better oral hygiene and reduced sugar intake.
Plenty of parents give their children undiluted fruit juice in the mistaken belief it's healthy. Worse, they often do so in bottles with teats or sippy cups.
Have a look at the sugar content of drinks aimed at younger children, it's pretty bad.
Increasing the price of those sugary drinks would give parents a clear and useful signal.
Governments should tax this and give subventions to those who wants to reach a more active healthy lifestyle.