News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by charlesdm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:51AM (#12424303)
In Europe, reverse engineering a protocol + building a commercial product on it, is legal. You cannot copyright a protocol or an API, if you built something merely by studying how it works.
Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by matheweis on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:57AM (#12424336)
The issue here is this appears likely to have been created by disassembly rather than pure study of behavior.

Is that legal in Europe?

Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by charlesdm on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:00AM (#12424352)
I'm not entirely sure of that. If you would have two teams though, it would. Team A creates a spec of the protocol, and Team B implements a connection lib based on the spec created by Team A.

Europe tends to be pretty good through, copyright wise.

Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by PieterH on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:11AM (#12424417)
Yes, clean-room reimplementations are legal everywhere. The problem with this code is it's not clean room. This leaves commercial users open to serious accusations of copyright infringement (as in, criminal prosecution.) See my comments in the thread. IANAL and my analysis is based on the README of the project.
Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by PieterH on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:13AM (#12424430)
Disassembly by a team that results in new code written by the same team is not legal in any country that enforces copyrights. That includes the EU. Possibly excludes Russia and probably excludes China unless the owner is a large Chinese company.

In fact I'd be surprised if this code isn't taken off GitHub by a DCMA from Microsoft, as soon as it hits their lawyers' radars.

Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by poizan42 on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:40AM (#12424551)
> Disassembly by a team that results in new code written by the same team is not legal in any country that enforces copyrights.

It's not illegal in itself. But you are easily opening yourself up to claims that the code you have written has been "tainted" by the disassembled code you have read and has therefore become a derivative work, which is going to be very to defend hard against.

Also note that even if it is decided that you have made a derivative work you might still successfully launch a fair use defense on the grounds on interoperability, see e.g. Sega v. Accolade[1].

That said, doing a proper clean-room reverse engineering with two teams kept separate is a much safer approach.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade

Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by PieterH on Sunday September 04, 2016 @02:23PM (#12425876)
Thanks for correcting me.
Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by kwhitefoot on Sunday September 04, 2016 @09:59AM (#12424347)
Probably. No DMCA here.
Re:Skypeopensource2 – Skype client based on reversing Skype 5.5 by ntauthority on Sunday September 04, 2016 @10:41AM (#12424556)
Directive 2009/24/EC has very similar implications, however.