News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Suicide’ Query Prompts Google to Offer Hotline by sokoloff on Monday April 05, 2010 @10:17AM (#1241944)
While I happen to agree with you on this specific case (and "approve" of this type of SERP monkeying), we should always be very cautious when on such extremely slippery slopes.

I would imagine that a pro-lifer would "hope they do everything they can to help people who are exploring their options [around an unplanned pregnancy], because amongst those options IS <what pro-lifers want>"

Similarly for religious or political or other moral topics. Should Google monkey with the SERPs for all of those topics? If so, who gets to decide in which direction it should be altered? (It happens that there isn't a very active group in support of suicide, euthansia aside, so this one is fairly non-controversial.)

Re:‘Suicide’ Query Prompts Google to Offer Hotline by dantheman on Monday April 05, 2010 @04:41PM (#1242998)
Google can do whatever they want -- there is no slippery slope; if you don't like what google is doing don't use it.
Re:‘Suicide’ Query Prompts Google to Offer Hotline by sesqu on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @07:35AM (#1244350)
And if I like some of what they do, but dislike some other bits of what they do, I should somewhat stop using them?

Like only using Google search for products and services I wish to be notified of by their sponsors, and Baidu search for products and services I would rather not be associated to my name, such as "spotted dick"? Sorry, I won't fly that flag.

If a service is almost what I need, I should be encouraged to provide guidance, not told it's their way or the highway. Especially considering that the larger the service provider, the more likely it is that the highway is theirs, and competitors either aren't supported by the market, aren't allowed by market instruments the provider has helped establish, or have comparable shortcomings.

If you disagree, don't reply. Write your own damn comments from scratch.

Re:‘Suicide’ Query Prompts Google to Offer Hotline by sesqu on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @10:19AM (#1244632)
That last part was a joke.
Re:‘Suicide’ Query Prompts Google to Offer Hotline by sokoloff on Tuesday April 06, 2010 @09:48AM (#1244563)
I agree that Google can do whatever they want. I was pointing out that they will only do this in extremely limited cases, because there most certainly IS a slippery slope here.