News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by TheOtherHobbes on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:16PM (#12414570)
What an astonishingly stupid and self-indulgently ignorant response.

The premise - that talent in sport is rare, and talent in socially useful services is plentiful - is nonsense.

Why don't we have phenomenal super-teachers and super-firemen? Is it because they don't exist? Are there really no incredibly talented individuals who can not only super-teach but also teach others how to super-teach?

Or is it because there's no process to find and reward them?

If it's the latter - why does that process not exist?

The answer isn't "Because there's no social demand for it." Education isn't exactly outstanding in the US, and super-teachers would do a lot to help the country's economic prospects.

But that doesn't happen for a simple reason: there's no easy way to make a short-term profit from them.

Profitability of socially valuable services is diffuse and long-term, and spread over the economy as a whole instead of being owned by a few individuals.

"Talented" sports people and actors follow the opposite pattern. They're selected and valued because they can be farmed for quick profit. This happens to correlate - to some extent - with special talent.

But in fact the number of sports business and movie studios is strictly limited. So it's actually quite likely that for every super-talent, there's a non-trivial number of individuals with similar talents who are never found and selected - precisely because it's more profitable to artificially limit their number to create the illusion of product scarcity.

There's nothing inherently wrong with a profit-driven economy. But when the economy becomes driven by short-term profitability, because its predictive horizon is too narrow to model the future accurately, good things stop happening.

There are no comments on this comment yet.