News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by quantumhobbit on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:06PM (#12413979)
It is wrong to compare Tom Brady to teachers in general. Instead you should compare athletes in general to teachers in general. Or compare best in class athletes to best in class teachers.

The general comparison would compare minor league baseball or local club soccer players to your kids kindergarten teacher. You might find that the teacher comes out on top.

The best in class comparison is harder. There are only 32? Nfl teams therefore there is enormous competition for the 32 best quarterbacks (maybe more including backups). If you are the #200 quarterback on the planet no one cares. Those selection dynamics don't happen for teachers. There might be some elite tutors who are highly sought out by wealthy parents, but not with the same intensity as quarterbacks.

This is compounded by the fact that sports skill is more easily measured than teaching skill. We might debate if Tom Brady is better than Peyton Manning, but it is obvious both are in the top ten in the world. Not so with teachers. Some are clearly better, but the clarity of ranking you can get with sports performance is impossible is any measure of teaching performance.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by drostie on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:26PM (#12414163)
Yeah, I would have expected that a domain called "Cafe Hayek" and a post title of "Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary" would have noticed that it's not a supply-side surplus that drives down these wages, but a complex interaction of how the demand-side works.

First off, we have the layers of oligopolization, like you've said: carefully marketed and individuated products for sports, film, and music ensure that there's a substantial profit margin there. It's not that there aren't indie films or small sports teams; it's that these companies have convinced people that this is their team and that their identity is mixed in with it, just the way that my girlfriend drinks Diet Coke and not pop.

Teaching is simultaneously much more cutthroat, with tons of schools that are constantly shifting composition and competing for the same slice of some dearth of public funds which first gets siphoned off by the occasionally-corrupt bureaucrats at the top, superintendents and such, who don't have nearly the accountability that the teachers do. Then there is a competition among the teachers, ameliorated somewhat by unions, but there is also a competition between the unions too. All of this ensures that there's money to spare for the pop cultures that's not there for the educational infrastructure. UNTIL... you get to colleges, where there are some colleges which have distinct identities; I still name-drop my undergraduate work at Cornell rather than my Master's at the TU Delft, even though the latter is a much greater achievement. There's a bit more pie around for the professors, and they enjoy much more cushy arrangements like tenure.

If you average over athletes in general, athletes get paid crap. Most of them are teenagers playing in exchange for being taken out for pizza afterwards; then there are adult amateurs and college-level play... You take the typical inner-city basketball player and evaluate his chances of making it to stardom, you're going to be talking about winning the lottery. Even if he has big dreams. Same with actors. But what you're actually seeing in these celebrities is a carefully-played oligopoly causing a great demand for a scarce product, and the scarcity drives these commitments to finding the best-of-the-best that allows stars to leverage that monopoly that all of us have in a free society, our monopoly on our own labor.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by Domenic_S on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:40PM (#12414306)
Did you just say that teaching is much more cutthroat than professional sports, music, and film? I'm trying to imagine the aspiring teaching doing late-night lectures in smoky bars for free, or teaching at the local teacher's club (again for free) so that one day they might reach their dream of being a professional teacher.

One day teaching might be cutthroat if we can ever figure out how to create some competition, but the only throat cutting that's happening is over internal politics, which is table stakes for any career worth pursuing.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by drostie on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:19PM (#12415040)
I mean, yes. I'm evaluating the teaching industry as a whole as being more competitive than the sports industry. I think you're mistaking different measures of competition, though, and we're possibly talking about the same thing in exactly opposite terms.

To get us back on the same page: Entering a new field is best thought of as a graph of how much you've been paid overall (the integral of your wages) minus job-related costs (student loans etc.) over time. Probably this time-axis is not "real time" but "time invested," as you may well be working for tips while trying to "break into" either teaching or acting. Now, there is some graph overlaid, which represents the amount you could have made doing other stuff (again in integral form, total profit you could have expected to make by that time pursuing other avenues). This is called an "opportunity cost" and often subtracted off of the original graph in some circles but I prefer to plot them side-by-side. In any case, find the t-position where these two graphs first cross and that (time, profit-to-date) break-even point is the "barrier to entry" into a new field. By the mean value theorem, sometime before you hit that point, the slope of your new career will have the slope of your old one, which is probably the definitive time when you "became a teacher" or "became an actor," rather than simply aspiring and doing stuff-on-the-side to break into the field. And sharper concavity on the curves suggests that this is closer or further from the break-even point.

OK, now that we've got the same picture in our heads: you're either measuring "cutthroatness" as either the time to become a teacher or that total break-even profit, and then you come to a natural conclusion that teaching, being a more gradual path to the point and having a lower point, is less cut-throat of a profession. I totally get that, and it's pretty persuasive.

However, what's salient for the economic theory is competitiveness for people who are already in the relevant industry. And that is where we cross terms, either inexactly (if you meant the first one) or exactly the reverse (if you meant the second one).

In standard macroeconomic theory, the magnitude of that break-even (profit, time) is the major factor determining how competitive the field is for the people who have already made it: a huge break-even investment means that the actors who have made it are going to make better wages.

One easy way to see this is to imagine a profession with no barriers to entry at all, something which anyone can just decide to go and do. (The stereotype of "fry cook" comes to mind.) In the long run, those are necessarily the least profitable professions, because anyone in a less-profitable profession will effortlessly switch to those professions, which will dilute profit in those professions and concentrate profit in the professions they're leaving, tending to equilibrate the two. Barriers to entry, whether those of copyright and patents or that of needing to fight for years to be recognized for your acting prowess, are the only things stopping the unwashed masses from coming in and making sport of it; it stands to reason that the bigger the barriers, the more of them are stopped.

In that sense, teaching is much more cutthroat than acting or sports or being a doctor; once you've made it as an actor/actress or an athlete or a doctor, you're now in the industry and therefore you're getting paid well, even if it cost you a lot to get in. You can enjoy a healthy security now that you've made it, precisely because it was so hard to make it, and everyone else needs to climb that mountain, too.

But if you're a teacher, your chance of having your school close or getting fired -- erm, "not asked to return" -- the next year is much higher, and you (a) know it and (b) often don't have the safety margin to easily afford it. You are much more replaceable than a professional athlete, therefore you have much less negotiating power at the table.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by platz on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:16PM (#12414062)
Where are the best in class teachers?

Are they hiding among the teachers in general? If they can't be identified, there is no effective & material differentiation (read: no justification for higher compensation) among them vs the less skilled.

Are you saying that the best teachers, in principle, could be measured, but we haven't developed the methods to do so (to be sure, a real possibility)? Or are they simply 'better' a-priori/intrinsically regardless if we can measure it or not?

The best in class athletes to best in class teachers comparison either fails or finds athletes winning flat out.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by drostie on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:33PM (#12414247)
Probably the most substantial difference is iteration. A footballer gets many games per year with many moments per game to potentially shine or fail publicly, with stats that can be evaluated year after year. Your success as a teacher can somewhat be evaluated via testing, but that seldom tracks something close to what you're really supposed to be doing: making a difference in your kids' lives. At best that's an evaluation that has to be made by the now-grown child themselves, several years after the interactions which occurred.
Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by quantumhobbit on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:33PM (#12414239)
I'm saying that it is harder to measure and that the measurement is inherently noisier for teachers. We measure teachers by how their students perform on standardized tests, which has all sorts of problems.

The more important factor is the value placed on differential performance. A 10% difference in teacher performance is lost in the noise. It likely wouldn't mean more money even if it could be measured easily. Whereas a 10% difference in football might mean being #1 in the draft versus going undrafted.

Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by eanzenberg on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:39PM (#12414295)
Private schools, international schools (if multi-lingual), private tutoring.
Re:Thinking at the Margin: It's Revolutionary by tpeo on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:55PM (#12414414)
Exactly. It doesn't make sense to compare the top individual of one ability's distribution to the average individual of another. There's a world of difference between a top football player and the average football player. I'd expect ability to be distributed along a power law, just like wages are.