News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by JoeAltmaier on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:00AM (#12413068)
I was following a giant wind generator blade down the highway on a windy day. Seen from the back (following the rig) I saw the thing twisting and bobbing constantly. Its like it was made of rubber!

Not an airplane wing, I know, but similar.

Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by jacquesm on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:25AM (#12413235)
Anything when made long enough will flex like that. Imagine that those blades are made of carbon fiber, resin and are designed for maximum stiffness!

Fortunately the loading of those blades is relatively constant, the majority of the load will come at a 90 degree angle to the plane of rotation, the angle at which the leading edge hits the apparent (not the real) wind. That apparent wind has a speed that is a fairly large multiple (7 or so) of the speed of the real wind and the 'flex' that you observe is almost all at right angles to that wind.

In other words: those blades are floppy in the direction where they can afford to be floppy, but extremely stiff along the axis where their main load is. If they wouldn't be the tips would lag behind the hub and they definitely do not do that in any significant amount.

Another good reason to make the blades a bit flexible in their long axis parallel to the tower is that this allows the blades to deal better with tower thump. A blade rigid in that dimension would cause a much sharper rise of the pressure wave of air trapped between the blade and the tower, and this results in a blade that will live that much longer (and a machine that runs quieter).

That is also the reason for the angle at which the nacelle is set, this creates a bit more room at the bottom where the blade flex is at its maximum, it also helps to offset wind-shear.

Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by Gravityloss on Sunday September 04, 2016 @04:42PM (#12426614)
Also, the shapes are nowadays pre-bent in the opposite direction, so they get more optimal when they are loaded. You can do many things in a wind turbine that would be dangerous in an aircraft.
Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by masklinn on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:41AM (#12413328)
Airplane wings will already twist and flex to pretty impressive extents, they're much less rigid than one would naively assume. This is dramatically visible during wing loading tests[0]

[0] https://youtu.be/B74_w3Ar9nI?t=78

Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by rayiner on Friday September 02, 2016 @10:50AM (#12413386)
Even during normal flight the tips of a 747 wing will move 6-7 feet. They're designed to be able to flex three times that distance.
Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by hodgesrm on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:30AM (#12413680)
Indeed. You can see this clearly on modern wide-bodies at takeoff if you sit over the wing. The wings droop until the aircraft hits liftoff velocity--at that point the wings lift up and you are wheels up a couple of seconds later. It's close to 10 feet at the tip on a Boeing 777, where the effect seems particularly pronounced.

It's also easy to observe wing movement easily during turbulence. I find it fun to watch but that's probably not to the taste of every passenger. On DC-10s you can also see the engines swinging on their mounts. That is a bit less enjoyable.

Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by jacquesm on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:57PM (#12416843)
The wingtips don't 'lift up', the body drops relative to the wing. Essentially the wing goes from hanging from the body to the body hanging off the wing.
Re:Future Airplanes Will Fly on Twistable Wings by hodgesrm on Saturday September 03, 2016 @09:46PM (#12422242)
I guess it depends on the frame of reference. The change happens while the plane is still on the runway before lift off.