Similarly, just because Ireland told Apple that they could get low taxes, doesn't mean that they were legally entitled to do so.
Your example is not applicable here since below minimum wages are illegal to begin with.
> Similarly, just because Ireland told Apple that they could get low taxes, doesn't mean that they were legally entitled to do so.
You are talking about the government here - not Apple. My point being - the Irish government was at fault when they broke EU law. Why should Apple be the one to compensate their error?
Ireland do not agree they provided any such exemption. Do you have evidence of a specific Exemption for apple?
1. http://www.hri.org/docs/Rome57/Part3Title05.html#Pt3TitVCha1...
1. Irish law (according to their interpretation) says it is ok 2. This interpretation was upheld by an Irish court.
Were all the other companies also paying 20% when you started, or were they paying 40% then?
Did your accountants and lawyers not notice the preferential treatment? Were they not aware of both Irish and EU laws?
As an individual tax payer, can I get similar treatment where the IRS confirms that my 1040 is correct? If I get bad advice from the IRS which causes me to fill out my 1040 incorrectly, am I not still liable for any owed taxes?
If I am liable, why should Apple not be liable? If I'm not liable, tell me how to get the IRS to review my taxes this way.
You got that wrong. They knew that the Irish tax rate was 12.5% for all corporations, but the government at the time offered them a super-extra-deal that - just for them - would bring that to 1%. Apple's lawyers were surely aware that this kind of special deals are very debatable in view of EU antitrust law, but took the deal anyway - at their own risk.
What was that deal? The Irish government claim no deal was made
The thing is, if my understanding of the facts is correct, it was a correct reading of the tax law, not some special one done for Apple. So this ruling was not a "deal."
1. Apple, like every other big corporation, uses a complex corporate structure in order to reduce taxes legally.
2. Irish government issues preferential rates and also advises Apple on how to do it, directly breaking EU law.
3. Five years later - Apple has to pay for the Ireland's preferential tax rates.
So let me get this straight - according to EU law if I get told today that Irish tax rate is 20% for example, 5 years down the line I can just expect someone to send me a letter stating that actually - I got preferential tax and I should repay another 20% on everything. Not to mention negative PR.
Can someone explain why people are angry at Apple when clearly they were allowed to do it?
It is interesting watching how emotionally invested people get in scorning corporations about legally reducing their taxes. Every small company owner I have talked to has tried a few ways of legally reducing taxes - I can't see why people hate on other people for doing the same thing.