This much is supported by the evidence, which is why it is so remarkable that MBAs typically attract orders of magnitude higher salaries than the average staffer, and having an MBA seems to be considered an advantage when applying for senior management positions in large businesses.
> but getting an MBA certainly doesn't make them less likely to succeed.
This much is not supported by any evidence I've seen so far in this discussion, so those of us who have only ever encountered MBAs who are walking stereotypes right out of this presentation find it a bit hard to believe.
Do you honestly think that MBA graduates attract high salaries for no reason? We live in a free market economy. Surely this must indicate to you that they generally provide more value than non-MBA graduates.
Do you realize that most MBA graduates have 5-7 years work experience before they even go to school? Then, after enhancing their own experiences with a framework provided by a business school and with the experiences of the other students, don't you think they are more developed for senior positions than someone without that extra educaton? It's so obvious to me why they would have an advantage to applying for senior management positions in large businesses. They are more qualified, in general!
For some reason, I feel like all the people here think that the only smart people in business are hackers that started a tech startup in their garage. This is not the only way to gain valuable experience and practical skills in business.
Maybe because you don't never observed it's rather easy to teach business to a scientist or an engineer, but it's nearly impossible to teach engineering or science to an MBA.
We need people who are skilled in business, but what we don't need is an echo chamber that encourages many of them to become arrogant, unethical, short-sighted fucks.
Saying that MBA programs nurture extreme arrogance, bad ethics and short sightedness is like saying that CS programs nurture introversion, poor social skills and an inability to communicate effectively.
There are tens of thousands of highly successful MBAs running or working in small businesses you've never heard of, not generating any noise, and contributing a great deal to society. To lump them all together as a bunch of frat boy lunatics is ignorant.
Any hacker that has a terrible experience with an MBA is going to write a blog post about how awful it was and how MBAs need to be cut out of the process. The truth is, there are plenty that provide a lot of value and insight, but no one writes about them because no one wants to read it.
I actually would say this, not about CS programs per se, but about academia.
There are tens of thousands of highly successful MBAs running or working in small businesses you've never heard of, not generating any noise, and contributing a great deal to society. To lump them all together as a bunch of frat boy lunatics is ignorant.
The same goes about PhDs and ex-academics. A lot of them are socially normal, but people tend to notice the aggregate tendencies and turn them into stereotypes. As for MBAs, I don't think the stereotype is remotely true of each individual, but it is true of a certain culture that exists in MBA programs. To be fair, I doubt it has much to do with programs themselves; the students track it in from investment banks and corporate boardrooms. So, even though the programs are designed with great intentions, a certain set of people get in and feed off each other. This is much like how prisons are supposed to reform criminals, but some of them just use the exposure to others to learn how to become better at crime.
1. There are more good Java hackers than good Lisp hackers, although the proportion of good programmers is much higher in the Lisp camp.
2. At this point, I'd put Java ahead of Perl for most purposes.
3. There are a lot of smart people who program but, for whatever reason, never become good programmers. Examples would be traders who use VB because it interfaces well with spreadsheets and scientists using Fortran. This shouldn't be terribly surprising; everyone speaks and writes but not all smart people are articulate and good writers.
There are certainly many different reasons for getting an MBA. Some people go just because you can demand a much high salary when you graduate. However, many others go to develop their analytical skills, expand their knowledge base, and meet highly capable individuals who have similar interests. Furthermore, most people getting MBAs have been in the workforce for 5-7 years. They are not trying to start the next Apple. They have found a niche in business they like and wish to accelerate their development.
If you have already started a successful business, then why would you get an MBA? You wouldn't, but if you don't have a large network of capable friends, what better way to meet one than by going back to school?
I love participating in this HN community, but think the amount of MBA bashing that goes on here is just ignorant. People aren't successful because they have an MBA, but getting an MBA certainly doesn't make them less likely to succeed. It's silly to generalize then marginalize a group of people because they do not take the same approach as the hackers here to making money and succeeding. Not everybody was meant to be a hacker, and while the members of this community should probably not be looking at getting MBAs, its stupid to have a disdain towards people who do.