Re:On Two Views of Computation in Computer Science
by pron on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @05:05PM
(#12401467)
Both models are equally powerful in the things they compute in terms of the Church-Turing Thesis. The TOP view also has other consideration. My point in the article was not to settle the debate on Aaronson's blog but to show that language models and machine models are objectively and inherently so different from one another that comparing them in terms of programming concepts (like types) is meaningless.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:On Two Views of Computation in Computer Science
by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @06:29PM
(#12401954)
And it seems that most of the "my way is superior to yours" is based on setting up strawmen of "yours" to make it be addressing the same questions as "mine".
Re:On Two Views of Computation in Computer Science
by pron on Thursday September 01, 2016 @03:25AM
(#12403607)
Yes, but it goes a little further. I can't say my way is superior to yours if my way means solving a harder task and paying market price for it.
I got the leather seats because I chose to pay full price for them. That they come as a standard option with the car because the car is more expensive is not an argument. You can choose to pay the same difference in price and have them installed in your car, too.
Whether those leather seats matter or not is no longer an objective question but a question of values, and here is where caring about completely different values is the point.