News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @03:03PM (#12400618)
> > Internet is a public good -> regulatory powers are voted on and enacted by public bodies who are transparent and can be voted out.

> You are also objectively wrong; the FCC, the primary Internet regulator, is not voted in and is in no way transparent.

The FCC has only the regulatory powers it is granted by statute, hence, "regulatory powers are voted on" is correct.

Those powers are enacted by Congress, which is an elected body which can be voted out.

The FCC is, in fact, governed by a number of transparency laws in the execution of its regulatory powers (and Congress has some degree of transparency, as well.)

So, I would say that your attempted rebuttal is more wrong than the post you are claiming is "objectively wrong".

Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by wyager on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @04:58PM (#12401424)
>Those powers are enacted by Congress, which is an elected body which can be voted out.

You mean the congress with an 11% approval rating? Yeah, that's going great.

Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by dllthomas on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @05:06PM (#12401478)
That's a misleading statistic. No one votes on "congress as a whole", they vote for their individual representatives. And individual representatives typically have a high approval rating (and are frequently voted out when it falls).
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by wyager on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @09:49PM (#12402691)
>No one votes on "congress as a whole"

Exactly. But congress as a whole would regulate the Internet.

Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by dllthomas on Thursday September 08, 2016 @01:27PM (#12455070)
I still say that's a little misleading. On any issue of national (or broader) scale, the people accounting for the difference between the behavior of my elected official (of whom I, statistically, approve) and the behavior of Congress as a whole must still be somehow contended with.